Skip to content

Head to head

Murderbot vs Severance

Severance takes it by 0.8, 8.9 against 8.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Murderbot
Murderbot

2025 · Excellent

  • Skarsgård plays a being that hates eye contact with a precise, physical deadpan
  • The voiceover keeps the books' sardonic inner monologue rather than explaining it away
  • The Preservation crew are broader and sillier than on the page, which dulls the stakes
Cover of Severance
Severance

2022 · Excellent

  • A premise that doubles as sharp satire of corporate loyalty and routine
  • Adam Scott and Britt Lower play two versions of one person with real nuance
  • The second season stalls in its middle stretch before regaining momentum

Where the gap is

Craft
7.79.5
Story
7.68.8
Characters
8.49.0
Performances
8.89.2

At a glance

FactMurderbotSeverance
Released16 May 202518 February 2022
Created byChris Weitz, Paul WeitzDan Erickson
StarringAlexander Skarsgård, Noma Dumezweni, David DastmalchianAdam Scott, Britt Lower, John Turturro
NetworkApple TV+ (now Apple TV)Apple TV+
Seasons12
Episodes1019
GenreAction · Sci-Fi · ComedySci-Fi · Drama · Mystery

The two verdicts

Murderbot

Murderbot: a deadpan android comedy that finds its heart in half-hour doses

Murderbot is a smaller show than its premise might suggest, and mostly the better for it. Skarsgård's performance and the preserved inner voice make the central character as funny and as quietly sad as it is on the page, and the half-hour format keeps a thin story moving more often than not. The score is held below the top tier by a supporting cast played too broadly for the danger to land, by action that never matches the dialogue, and by a middle stretch that shows how little plot one novella holds. As a comedy about a being who would rather be anywhere than in company, it is a pleasure, and the renewal gives it room to grow into the darker material the later books provide.

Read the full review →

Severance

Severance: office satire sharpened into television's most unnerving mystery box

Severance is a rare series whose concept, performances and visual identity all pull in the same direction. The first season is close to a modern classic; the second is ambitious, occasionally baggy and still frequently brilliant. The uneven pacing keeps it just short of the very top tier, but an 8.9 reflects a show that is richly imagined, superbly acted and unlike anything else on television.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.