Skip to content

Head to head

My Dress-Up Darling vs Scott Pilgrim Takes Off

Dead level: both score 7.6. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of My Dress-Up Darling
  • Marin's unselfconscious enthusiasm makes her a joyful, magnetic lead
  • Detailed focus on costume-making, wigs and make-up is fascinating
  • Frequent fan service and lingering camera work undercut the gentle romance
Cover of Scott Pilgrim Takes Off
  • Science SARU's vibrant animation captures the comic's video-game energy
  • Ramona and the evil exes gain welcome depth and personality
  • An early swerve away from the familiar story frustrates some viewers

Where the gap is

Sound
7.48.4
Story
7.27.2
Animation
8.59.1
Characters
8.37.8

At a glance

FactMy Dress-Up DarlingScott Pilgrim Takes Off
Released9 January 202217 November 2023
StudioCloverWorksScience Saru
Episodes128
StatusCompletedCompleted
GenreComedy · Romance · Slice of LifeAction · Comedy · Romance

The two verdicts

My Dress-Up Darling

My Dress-Up Darling: a sweet rom-com that takes the craft of cosplay seriously

My Dress-Up Darling is a warm, polished and endearing romantic comedy with an excellent lead and a genuine love for craft. Its heavy fan service, repetitive embarrassment gags and slow narrative progress are notable weaknesses. It was very popular on release, and a 7.6 reflects a good series whose charm frequently outweighs its flaws.

Read the full review →

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off: a bold remix that trusts fans to follow it somewhere new

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off earns its score through gorgeous animation, a lively returning cast and a genuinely thoughtful expansion of characters who deserved more attention. Its central gamble will not work for everyone, and a compressed run and some navel-gazing in the finale blunt its impact, but it is a creative, affectionate reinvention rather than a simple nostalgia exercise.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.