Skip to content

Head to head

One Punch Man vs The Rose of Versailles

Dead level: both score 8.7. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of One Punch Man
One Punch Man

2015 · Excellent

  • Explosive fight animation that stands among the best seen on television
  • Deadpan comedy that skewers shonen and superhero conventions
  • The central joke limits dramatic tension by design
Cover of The Rose of Versailles
The Rose of Versailles

1979 · Excellent

  • Oscar is a soldier with a job, a temper and doubts, not a costume or a gimmick
  • Osamu Dezaki's second half turns split screens and held stills into real drama
  • The opening episodes lean on shrill court melodrama and broad villains

Where the gap is

Sound
8.78.3
Story
7.99.1
Animation
9.68.0
Characters
8.59.3

At a glance

FactOne Punch ManThe Rose of Versailles
Released5 October 201510 October 1979
StudioMadhouseTokyo Movie Shinsha, TMS Entertainment
Episodes1240
StatusCompletedCompleted
GenreAction · Comedy · SuperheroDrama · Romance · Historical
Director—Tadao Nagahama, Osamu Dezaki

The two verdicts

One Punch Man

One Punch Man: a superhero parody animated with more craft than most sincere epics

One Punch Man's first season earns its high score through animation that remains a benchmark and comedy that makes a single joke feel endlessly renewable. The deliberately absent tension and an unfinished story hold it back from the very top, but as a short, sharp showcase of what television action can look like, it is outstanding.

Read the full review →

The Rose of Versailles

The Rose of Versailles: a court romance that grows into a political tragedy

The Rose of Versailles earns its reputation the slow way. Its first episodes are a gaudy costume drama that could have been forgettable, and its animation never escapes the economics of 1979 television. But the series grows up alongside its heroine, and by the time Dezaki is in charge it has become a serious drama about class and conscience, staged with an inventiveness that later directors would borrow for decades. Oscar remains the best reason to watch: a character conceived in 1972 who still feels modern, because the show takes her work as seriously as her heart. The score sits in the high eights rather than higher because the opening stretch tests patience and the craft is uneven. For anyone interested in where anime's romantic and political ambitions meet, it belongs near the top of any viewing list.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.