Skip to content

Head to head

Preacher vs Spider-Man: Blue

Preacher takes it by 0.1, 7.8 against 7.7. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Preacher
Preacher

1995 · Good

  • An audacious premise that takes on religion, America and masculinity
  • Jesse, Tulip and Cassidy form a vivid, messy and loyal central trio
  • Gross-out gags and homophobic jokes have aged poorly
Cover of Spider-Man: Blue
Spider-Man: Blue

2002 · Good

  • Tim Sale's warm, retro art beautifully captures the 1960s Romita era
  • Gwen Stacy is given a depth and charm often missing from the originals
  • The villain encounters are thin and feel like filler

Where the gap is

Art
8.29.0
Story
7.96.9
Pacing
7.07.2
Characters
8.48.1

At a glance

FactPreacherSpider-Man: Blue
Released1 April 19951 July 2002
WriterGarth EnnisJeph Loeb
ArtistGlenn Fabry, Steve Dillon—
PublisherVertigoMarvel Comics
Issues666
GenreAction · Drama · Black comedyRomance · Superhero

The two verdicts

Preacher

Preacher is a profane, blasphemous road trip with a surprisingly old-fashioned heart

Preacher is a bold, funny and genuinely affecting series, powered by three terrific central characters and a willingness to ask big questions about faith and morality. Its dated shock humour, meandering middle and conflicted view of masculinity hold it back. A 7.8 reflects a good, often brilliant series that time has not treated kindly.

Read the full review →

Spider-Man: Blue

Spider-Man: Blue is a tender, lovely valentine that barely has a story to tell

Spider-Man: Blue is a beautifully drawn and affectionate tribute to Peter Parker's youth and to Gwen Stacy, with a sincerity that makes its best moments land. Thin plotting, perfunctory villains and a reliance on nostalgia keep it from being essential. A 7.7 reflects a good, heartfelt miniseries that is more mood piece than story.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.