Skip to content

Head to head

Random Access Memories vs To Pimp a Butterfly

To Pimp a Butterfly takes it by 1.3, 9.4 against 8.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Random Access Memories
Random Access Memories

2013 · Excellent

  • Recording quality and live musicianship of astonishing polish
  • Get Lucky and Instant Crush are warm, memorable pop songs
  • At well over an hour, mid-album tracks such as Motherboard drag
Cover of To Pimp a Butterfly
To Pimp a Butterfly

2015 · Essential

  • A rich blend of jazz, funk and soul played by a stellar band
  • Alright became an enduring anthem of protest and resilience
  • Nearly 80 minutes of dense material makes it demanding to revisit

Where the gap is

Cohesion
7.69.3
Production
9.59.4
Performance
8.99.6
Songwriting
7.89.7

At a glance

FactRandom Access MemoriesTo Pimp a Butterfly
Released17 May 201315 March 2015
ArtistDaft PunkKendrick Lamar
LabelColumbia RecordsInterscope Records, Top Dawg Entertainment
Tracks1316
Length74:2478:51
GenreFunk · Electronic · DiscoHip-hop · Jazz · Funk

The two verdicts

Random Access Memories

Random Access Memories: Daft Punk's lavish, flawed love letter to live musicians

Random Access Memories scores 8.1. Its production, performances and best songs are superb, and its commercial and critical success, including a Grammy for Album of the Year, confirmed its standing. But its length, mid-album lull and occasional preference for homage over invention keep it from the top tier of Daft Punk's catalogue.

Read the full review →

To Pimp a Butterfly

To Pimp a Butterfly: Kendrick Lamar's dense, jazz-soaked reckoning with America

To Pimp a Butterfly scores 9.4: an exceptional album, and one of the defining artistic statements of its era. Its songwriting, performances and musical ambition are almost unmatched in modern hip-hop, and its cultural impact has been profound. Its length and density keep it just short of the landmark tier for some listeners, but its achievement is undeniable.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.