Skip to content

Head to head

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off vs Skip and Loafer

Skip and Loafer takes it by 0.9, 8.5 against 7.6. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Scott Pilgrim Takes Off
  • Science SARU's vibrant animation captures the comic's video-game energy
  • Ramona and the evil exes gain welcome depth and personality
  • An early swerve away from the familiar story frustrates some viewers
Cover of Skip and Loafer
Skip and Loafer

2023 · Excellent

  • Mitsumi is a delightful, funny lead without being a cartoon
  • Supporting characters are drawn with rare empathy and nuance
  • Low stakes and a gentle pace will not suit viewers who want drama

Where the gap is

Sound
8.47.9
Story
7.28.1
Animation
9.18.4
Characters
7.89.2

At a glance

FactScott Pilgrim Takes OffSkip and Loafer
Released17 November 20234 April 2023
StudioScience SaruP.A. Works
Episodes812
StatusCompletedCompleted
GenreAction · Comedy · RomanceComedy · Romance · Slice of Life

The two verdicts

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off: a bold remix that trusts fans to follow it somewhere new

Scott Pilgrim Takes Off earns its score through gorgeous animation, a lively returning cast and a genuinely thoughtful expansion of characters who deserved more attention. Its central gamble will not work for everyone, and a compressed run and some navel-gazing in the finale blunt its impact, but it is a creative, affectionate reinvention rather than a simple nostalgia exercise.

Read the full review →

Skip and Loafer

Skip and Loafer: a sunny school comedy with a surprisingly wise heart

Skip and Loafer earns its score through superb character writing, a funny and endearing lead, and an unusually empathetic eye for the social pressures of adolescence. Its gentle pace, forgettable music and open-ended conclusion keep it from the top tier, but as a slice-of-life comedy it is about as good-natured and insightful as the genre gets.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.