Skip to content

Head to head

Split Fiction vs Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Dead level: both score 9.1. What separates them is what they are for, not how good they are.

Cover of Split Fiction
Split Fiction

2025 · Essential

  • Nearly every chapter builds a new mechanic, uses it well, then retires it
  • The moving split-screen makes each player read the other half of the puzzle
  • The script explains feelings the level design has already made obvious
Cover of Super Smash Bros. Ultimate
  • An unprecedented roster spanning decades of Nintendo and third-party history
  • Faster, tighter fighting than the previous entry, accessible yet deep
  • Online play suffers from lag and inconsistent matchmaking

Where the gap is

Story
7.86.0
Gameplay
9.59.3
Longevity
7.99.6
Presentation
9.29.4

At a glance

FactSplit FictionSuper Smash Bros. Ultimate
Released6 March 20257 December 2018
DeveloperHazelight StudiosSora, Bandai Namco Studios
PublisherElectronic ArtsNintendo
PlatformsPC (Windows), PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X|S, Nintendo Switch 2Nintendo Switch
DirectorJosef FaresMasahiro Sakurai
EngineUnreal Engine 5Custom
GenreAction · Adventure · Co-opAction

The two verdicts

Split Fiction

Split Fiction: Hazelight spends its best ideas faster than anyone else dares

Split Fiction is the most inventive co-op game of its generation, and it earns that by refusing to be efficient. Hazelight builds mechanics that most studios would ration across a whole campaign, uses each one for a single chapter, and moves on, and it sustains that pace for eight chapters without a dead stretch. The cost is a story that states its themes rather than dramatising them, and a game with little to offer once it is over: no difficulty worth conquering, no systems to take apart, no second run that differs from the first. Judged as the thing it is, an evening or three of two people surprising each other, almost nothing in the medium comes close.

Read the full review →

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is a museum of gaming that also plays brilliantly

Super Smash Bros. Ultimate is a generous, fast and finely tuned crossover fighter whose roster, stages and music make it a lasting celebration of the medium. Unreliable online play, a padded adventure mode and a slow unlocking process are its clearest failings, but they barely dent one of the finest party fighters ever made.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.