Skip to content

Head to head

The Color Purple vs The House of the Spirits

The Color Purple takes it by 0.6, 8.9 against 8.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Color Purple
The Color Purple

1982 · Excellent

  • Celie's voice, raw and increasingly confident, is extraordinary
  • A vivid, loving portrait of female friendship and solidarity
  • Nettie's missionary letters slow the pace and can feel didactic
Cover of The House of the Spirits
The House of the Spirits

1982 · Excellent

  • Clara del Valle is an enchanting, unforgettable presence
  • Blends family drama and political history into a gripping sweep
  • Its magical realism owes a heavy and obvious debt to García Márquez

Where the gap is

Ideas
8.88.2
Story
8.58.3
Writing
9.18.5
Characters
9.38.6

At a glance

FactThe Color PurpleThe House of the Spirits
Released19821982
AuthorAlice WalkerIsabel Allende
PublisherHarcourtSudamericana
Pages295433
GenreDrama · Literary fictionDrama · Magical realism · Literary fiction

The two verdicts

The Color Purple

The Color Purple: Alice Walker's letters of pain and survival still sing

The Color Purple is an extraordinary novel built on one of fiction's most compelling narrators, a moving celebration of friendship and love, and a searing account of racism and patriarchy. Its slower strand of letters and its neat resolution keep it just short of the highest tier, but its voice and humanity make it an exceptional and enduring book.

Read the full review →

The House of the Spirits

The House of the Spirits: Isabel Allende's family saga turns magic into witness

The House of the Spirits is an ambitious, absorbing debut that combines magical storytelling with a searing account of political violence. Its derivative early style, uneven tone and difficult central figure hold it back from the very highest ranks, but its characters, especially Clara and Alba, and its commitment to memory and witness make it an excellent and moving novel.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.