Skip to content

Head to head

The Hobbit vs The Lord of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings takes it by 0.7, 9.6 against 8.9. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Hobbit
The Hobbit

1937 · Excellent

  • Bilbo's growth from homebody to hero is charming and believable
  • The riddle game in the dark is a classic scene of tension
  • Most of the thirteen dwarves are indistinguishable from one another
Cover of The Lord of the Rings
The Lord of the Rings

1954 · Masterpiece

  • Middle-earth's languages, histories and geography give it unmatched depth
  • Sam and Frodo's friendship is one of fiction's great depictions of loyalty
  • The long opening in the Shire and Old Forest tests newcomers' patience

Where the gap is

Ideas
8.49.7
Story
8.79.6
Writing
8.99.1
Characters
8.19.0

At a glance

FactThe HobbitThe Lord of the Rings
Released21 September 193729 July 1954
AuthorJ.R.R. TolkienJ.R.R. Tolkien
PublisherHarperCollinsGeorge Allen & Unwin Limited
Pages3101178
GenreAdventure · FantasyAdventure · Fantasy

The two verdicts

The Hobbit

The Hobbit: a cosy adventure that grows into something wiser and darker

The Hobbit is a warm, witty and inventive adventure that deepens into a meditation on greed and courage. Undeveloped dwarves, an intrusive narrator and some convenient escapes keep it just below the highest tier, but its imagination, humour and moral heart make it an excellent classic, and a perfect gateway to Middle-earth.

Read the full review →

The Lord of the Rings

The Lord of the Rings: the template for modern fantasy remains its high-water mark

The Lord of the Rings has faults that are easy to list: a meandering opening, a narrow range of female roles and a high style that is not to all tastes. Yet the depth of its world, the moral seriousness of its themes and the emotional power of its central friendship are unrivalled. It is an all-time landmark, and it continues to justify its reputation.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.