Skip to content

Head to head

The Tatami Galaxy vs Toradora!

The Tatami Galaxy takes it by 1.0, 8.9 against 7.9. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Tatami Galaxy
The Tatami Galaxy

2010 · Excellent

  • Each episode restarts the same two years, so the jokes compound instead of repeating
  • Flat, poster-like designs and collage make its Kyoto look like nowhere else
  • The narration is so fast that subtitles leave little time to look at the images
Cover of Toradora!
Toradora!

2008 · Good

  • A central pair whose bond develops with warmth and real emotional logic
  • Ami and Minori become far richer than their initial archetypes
  • Taiga's early violence towards Ryuji is played for laughs and grates

Where the gap is

Sound
8.67.8
Story
9.07.6
Animation
9.37.4
Characters
8.88.5

At a glance

FactThe Tatami GalaxyToradora!
Released23 April 20102 October 2008
StudioMadhouseJ.C.Staff
DirectorMasaaki YuasaTatsuyuki Nagai
Episodes1125
StatusCompletedCompleted
GenreDrama · Comedy · RomanceComedy · Romance · Slice of Life

The two verdicts

The Tatami Galaxy

The Tatami Galaxy: eleven do-overs that turn regret into the funniest anime of its decade

The Tatami Galaxy takes the oldest consolation in fiction, that things might have gone differently, and turns it into eleven episodes of escalating comedy that end up somewhere surprisingly tender. Yuasa's direction is the main reason: the flat, collaged images and the torrential narration create a rhythm no other series of its year attempted, and they make repetition feel like accumulation. The score stops short of the very top because the middle stretch does lean on its formula, because Akashi stays more idea than person, and because the subtitle-heavy delivery will lose some viewers early. For those who stay, it is the clearest single statement of one of animation's most distinctive directors, and a story about wasted time that wastes none of its own.

Read the full review →

Toradora!

Toradora!: a rom-com that grows up in front of its audience, mostly gracefully

Toradora! earns its score through well-developed characters, a central relationship with genuine warmth and several episodes of real emotional power. Its dated comic violence, uneven adult subplots and a rushed, melodramatic finale keep it in the high sevens, but for viewers who enjoy romantic comedies that turn sincere, it remains a rewarding and much-loved series.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.