Alan Wake 2 · 2023
Alan Wake 2: Remedy's boldest, strangest and most confident horror game
Alan Wake 2 review: Remedy's survival horror sequel splits a nightmare between an FBI profiler and a trapped novelist, and mostly pulls it off.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Alan Wake 2 is the game Remedy has spent its whole career edging towards: a horror story that is also a story about writing horror, told with a formal daring that most big-budget studios would not risk. It is slower and more deliberate than the action-thriller original, trading pulp momentum for dread, and it is all the better for it.
- 8.9
- Editorial score
- #53
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 9.5
- Best at: Presentation
It is not flawless. The shooting that underpins its survival horror loop is serviceable rather than exciting, and the opening hours move at a crawl. But as a piece of atmosphere, structure and audiovisual invention, it stands among the most distinctive releases of its generation.
Lighting is superb throughout, from forest clearings lit by flares to rain-slicked Dark Place alleys.
How it plays
Both protagonists fight the same way: burn away the darkness shielding an enemy with a flashlight, then finish them with conventional firearms. Ammunition is scarce, dodging is essential and encounters are tense early on. The trouble is that the enemy roster is thin, and by the later chapters fights feel like interruptions rather than escalations of the horror.
Where the design shines is in its investigative layers. Saga can retreat into the Mind Place, a mental case room where clues are pinned to a board and suspects are profiled. It is essentially an interactive notebook, but it gives the procedural half a satisfying rhythm of gathering, connecting and deducing. Alan's equivalent, the Writer's Room, lets him rewrite scenes by applying plot ideas to locations, physically reshaping the Dark Place. Neither system is especially difficult, yet both make the player feel complicit in the storytelling.

World and story
Bright Falls and the neighbouring town of Watery are rendered as damp, lived-in places full of cult iconography, local oddballs and radio broadcasts. The Dark Place is the opposite: a looping, hostile Manhattan of subway tunnels and neon, where the geography itself cannot be trusted. Moving between the two is where the game finds its unease.
The script is knowing, frequently funny and occasionally indulgent. It folds in the wider Remedy Connected Universe, and players who never touched Control or the original Alan Wake will miss a fair share of its references. Even so, the central mystery of who is writing whom is handled with enough clarity that newcomers can follow the thread, if not every knot in it.
Presentation
This is where Alan Wake 2 is at its most extraordinary. Remedy weaves live-action video into scenes, projecting faces into the environment and cutting between footage and real-time rendering without breaking the mood. Lighting is superb throughout, from forest clearings lit by flares to rain-slicked Dark Place alleys.
One chapter in particular, built around the in-universe rock band Old Gods of Asgard, has become a talking point for good reason. It is a bravura, theatrical sequence that shows exactly how far the studio is willing to push the medium. Sound design is similarly careful, with whispers and distorted voices doing much of the heavy lifting.
The engine is demanding, however, and at launch the PC version asked a lot of older hardware.
Who it is for
This is for players who value atmosphere and narrative ambition over mechanical depth. Fans of slow-burn survival horror and of Remedy's peculiar sense of humour will find plenty to chew on, and the later expansions add further curiosities. Anyone after a tight action game or a scare-a-minute experience may find it too talky and too measured.
What works
- Two campaigns that genuinely inform and unsettle one another
- Live-action footage blended into the game world with real confidence
- Saga's Mind Place turns detective work into a satisfying ritual
- A mid-game musical set piece that few studios would dare attempt
What doesn’t
- Combat is stiff and repetitive once the novelty of the flashlight fades
- A slow first act that asks for patience before it grips
- Leans heavily on knowledge of Control and the first game
Head to head
- Story
- 9.38.3
- Gameplay
- 7.99.4
- Longevity
- 7.68.8
- Presentation
- 9.59.2
Resident Evil 4 Remake edges it by 0.3. See them side by side
The verdict
Alan Wake 2 earns its high score on the strength of its storytelling, structure and presentation, which are exceptional and often genuinely original. Its combat and pacing hold it back from the very top tier, but few horror games of recent years are as memorable, as ambitious or as unmistakably the work of one studio's singular vision.





