Red Dead Redemption 2 · 2018
Red Dead Redemption 2 is a slow, devastating elegy for the outlaw West
Red Dead Redemption 2 follows Arthur Morgan and the Van der Linde gang through a richly detailed West. Deliberately slow, deeply moving and unforgettable.
Masterpiece
Editorial score out of 10
Red Dead Redemption 2 is an open-world game that insists on being lived in rather than consumed. Its horses need care, its hunting is methodical, and its story takes its time. For some players, that commitment to realism is exhausting. For many more, it produces one of the most immersive and emotionally resonant games ever made.
- 9.5
- Editorial score
- #5
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2018
- Released
- 9.9
- Best at: Presentation
Its heart is Arthur Morgan, and the story of a man slowly reckoning with the life he has chosen.
Players who enjoy immersive worlds, character-driven stories and a slower pace should consider it essential.
How it plays
Rockstar prioritises texture over speed. Arthur must eat, sleep and keep his weapons clean. Horses form bonds with their riders and respond to careful handling. Looting a body or skinning an animal plays out in full animation. Gunfights use a deliberate cover system and the Dead Eye targeting ability, and they feel weighty, even if aiming is heavier than in faster shooters.
The open world is where the game shines. Encounters emerge naturally, whether a stranger asking for help, an ambush on the road or a chance meeting in the wilderness. The honour system responds to how Arthur treats people, affecting interactions and certain story moments.
The main missions are more constrained. Many follow strict paths and fail players for deviating, producing a conflict between the freedom of the world and the rigidity of the narrative set pieces. The controls, with context-sensitive button assignments that can clash, occasionally frustrate as well.

World and story
The world is a triumph of craft. From snow-covered peaks to humid bayous and the bustling city of Saint Denis, each region feels distinct, with wildlife, weather and people behaving convincingly. The attention to detail extends to small interactions that most players will never notice.
The gang's camp is the story's emotional centre. Arthur can chat with members, contribute supplies and take part in small moments of life, and these interactions build a sense of family that makes its gradual fracturing painful. Dutch van der Linde, the charismatic leader, is a fascinating presence.
Arthur's arc is the finest element. Roger Clark's performance captures a man torn between loyalty and conscience, and the writing allows him to change gradually and believably. The pacing is slow, particularly in the opening hours, but the patience is rewarded with a story that many regard as among the finest in the medium.
Presentation
The technical and artistic achievement remains remarkable. Lighting, weather and landscapes create painterly vistas, and character animation is unusually natural. Woody Jackson's score moves between quiet ambience and powerful themes, and the handful of original songs are used sparingly and to devastating effect.
Who it is for
Players who enjoy immersive worlds, character-driven stories and a slower pace should consider it essential. Those who want fast action, snappy controls or a tightly focused campaign may find its deliberate design frustrating. Red Dead Online offers a different, more grind-based experience.
What works
- Arthur Morgan is one of the richest, most complex protagonists in games
- An astonishingly detailed world full of unscripted encounters and life
- Camp life makes the gang feel like a real, fracturing family
- Superb score and performances give key moments tremendous weight
What doesn’t
- Heavy, deliberate controls and long animations can feel sluggish
- Story missions are rigid and punish attempts to improvise
- A slow opening that tests patience before the world truly opens
Head to head
- Story
- 9.87.8
- Gameplay
- 8.59.8
- Longevity
- 9.49.6
- Presentation
- 9.99.4
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild edges it by 0.2. See them side by side
The verdict
Red Dead Redemption 2 combines a breathtakingly detailed world with a profoundly moving central story and a protagonist who ranks among gaming's best. Its heavy controls, rigid missions and slow opening are real drawbacks, but the ambition, craft and emotional power of the whole mark it as a landmark of the medium.





