Baby Reindeer · 2024
Baby Reindeer: a raw, brave confession that is hard to watch and harder to forget
Our review of Baby Reindeer, Richard Gadd's Netflix drama: a fearless, uncomfortable study of obsession and abuse, with outstanding performances throughout.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Baby Reindeer is not a comfortable watch, and it does not want to be. Richard Gadd's adaptation of his own one-man show is a story about being stalked that gradually reveals itself as something more painful: a portrait of shame, of how abuse distorts a person's sense of what they deserve, and of the strange mutual need that can bind a victim to the person tormenting him.
- 8.3
- Editorial score
- #51
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2024
- Released
- 1
- Seasons
It became one of the most talked-about series of its year, and the conversation around it was not only about its quality. Its presentation as a true story led to intense online speculation about the real people involved and to legal action against Netflix. That context is impossible to ignore, and it raises fair questions about the responsibilities of autobiographical drama, even as the work itself remains remarkable.
For those prepared for its intensity, it offers one of the most honest depictions of male victimhood on television.
The story
The premise could have been a thriller: a lonely woman fixates on a bartender and will not let go. Gadd resists that genre almost entirely. Martha's harassment is rendered through a relentless drip of emails and voicemails, and the dread comes from repetition rather than jump scares. What makes the series distinctive is its honesty about Donny's own behaviour. He is flattered by the attention, reluctant to report it, and at times cruel to the people who love him.
The fourth episode, which turns back to a period when Donny was groomed and abused by an older man in the comedy world, is the heart of the series. It is harrowing but never gratuitous, and it reframes everything that came before. After it, the remaining episodes necessarily lose a little tension, and the ending feels less sharply shaped than the middle.

Performances
Jessica Gunning's performance is extraordinary. Martha is loud, funny, delusional and genuinely menacing, and Gunning never lets the character become a monster or a punchline. Gadd is equally exposed as Donny, playing a version of himself who is often unlikeable with a candour few performers would risk. Nava Mau, as Donny's girlfriend Teri, gives the series a moral clarity it badly needs, and Tom Goodman-Hill is chilling as a television writer who offers Donny a way into the industry.
Craft
Directed by Weronika Tofilska and Josephine Bornebusch, the series has a grubby, close-up texture that suits its subject. Messages appear on screen with their original misspellings, turning Martha's voice into a constant presence. The main craft weakness is the reliance on voiceover: Donny's narration is often insightful but sometimes explains emotions the performances have already made clear.
Who it is for
This is serious, adult drama that deals explicitly with sexual abuse, addiction and mental illness, and viewers should approach it with that in mind. For those prepared for its intensity, it offers one of the most honest depictions of male victimhood on television.
What works
- Jessica Gunning makes Martha frightening, funny and pitiable at once
- Gadd refuses to cast himself as a blameless victim
- The fourth episode is an unflinching, devastating piece of drama
- Nava Mau brings warmth and clarity as Donny's girlfriend Teri
What doesn’t
- Heavy voiceover sometimes tells what the images already show
- Its true-story billing raised serious real-world questions after release
- The final episodes lose some focus as the threads are tied up
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.08.1
- Story
- 8.46.8
- Characters
- 8.68.0
- Performances
- 9.39.2
Baby Reindeer edges it by 0.8. See them side by side
The verdict
Baby Reindeer scores 8.3 for the courage of its writing, two exceptional central performances and a fourth episode that ranks among the most powerful hours of recent drama. Its overused narration, looser final stretch and the unresolved ethical questions raised by its true-story framing keep it from a higher mark, but it is essential viewing for anyone interested in how television can confront trauma.





