The Wire · 2002
The Wire: the closest television has come to the great American novel
The Wire review: David Simon's HBO drama about Baltimore's drug trade, docks, politics, schools and press is a towering, unsparing portrait of an American city.
Masterpiece
Editorial score out of 10
The Wire is often described as the greatest television drama ever made, and after all this time, the claim still holds up. David Simon and Ed Burns, drawing on their experience as a journalist and a detective, set out to depict an American city through its institutions, showing how the drug trade, law enforcement, labour, politics, education and media interact to produce inequality and failure. The result is an epic of astonishing ambition and humanity.
- 9.8
- Editorial score
- #1
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2002
- Released
- 5
- Seasons
It is not an easy watch. The early episodes are slow, the cast is enormous and the show refuses conventional payoffs. But those who invest will find a work of rare depth.
The young actors in the fourth season, including Maestro Harrell, Jermaine Crawford, Julito McCullum and Tristan Wilds, are superb.
Story
The first season, following a detail of detectives building a case against Avon Barksdale's organisation and his lieutenant Stringer Bell, establishes the show's approach. Rather than presenting a simple battle between good and evil, it shows parallel hierarchies, with officers and dealers alike navigating bosses, bureaucracy and personal ambition.
Each season expands the canvas. The second turns to the decline of the city's port and the working-class men who depend on it. The third examines the politics of reform, including a radical police experiment in drug decriminalisation. The fourth, widely considered the show's peak, follows four boys in the city's schools, a heartbreaking look at how children are failed by every institution around them. The fifth focuses on a local newspaper and a police department under strain; it has powerful moments, but its media critique feels more pointed, and a central subplot strains credibility.

Characters and performances
The ensemble is extraordinary. Dominic West's Jimmy McNulty is a talented, self-destructive detective, while Wendell Pierce's Bunk and Clarke Peters's methodical Lester Freamon are gems. Idris Elba's Stringer Bell, a drug lieutenant with business-school aspirations, and Wood Harris's Avon Barksdale embody the complexity of the criminal world. Michael K. Williams's Omar Little, a shotgun-wielding stick-up man who robs dealers and lives by a strict code, is one of television's most iconic characters.
Andre Royo's Bubbles, a heroin addict and informant, is a heartbreaking portrait. Lance Reddick's upright Cedric Daniels, Sonja Sohn's Kima Greggs and Aidan Gillen's ambitious politician Tommy Carcetti add further depth. The young actors in the fourth season, including Maestro Harrell, Jermaine Crawford, Julito McCullum and Tristan Wilds, are superb.
Craft
The Wire's style is naturalistic and understated, favouring real Baltimore locations, minimal score and long scenes that allow characters to talk. Its writers' room included acclaimed crime novelists such as George Pelecanos, Richard Price and Dennis Lehane, contributing to its literary texture. The opening theme, Tom Waits's Way Down in the Hole, is performed by a different artist each season, a small but telling touch.
Who it is for
The Wire is essential viewing for anyone interested in television, crime drama or social issues. It demands patience and attention, particularly in its first episodes, and those who prefer fast-paced storytelling may struggle initially. Viewers who persist will find a series that changes how they see cities and institutions.
What works
- Treats cops, dealers, dockworkers and politicians with equal complexity
- The fourth season's school storyline is devastating and profoundly humane
- Michael K. Williams's Omar Little is a legendary television character
- Dialogue has an authentic, profane poetry rooted in Baltimore life
What doesn’t
- The deliberately slow opening episodes demand real patience
- The fifth season's newspaper storyline is weaker and more didactic
- Dense slang and a vast cast can make early episodes hard to follow
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.47.3
- Story
- 9.86.8
- Characters
- 9.97.4
- Performances
- 9.68.4
The Wire edges it by 2.5. See them side by side
The verdict
The Wire is a monumental achievement, combining meticulous storytelling, unforgettable characters and profound social insight. Its demanding pace and weaker final season are minor flaws in a work of such scope and power. A 9.8 marks it as an all-time landmark of the medium.





