Dexter · 2006
Dexter: a thrilling antihero study that squandered its best years
Our review of Dexter, Showtime's serial-killer drama: brilliant early seasons led by Michael C. Hall, followed by a long, frustrating decline.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
In its early years, Dexter was one of the most compelling dramas on American television: a sunny Miami crime show with a murderer as its narrator, asking viewers to root for a man who kills people and then questioning why they did. Michael C. Hall's performance, and the queasy wit of the premise, made it a cable sensation and a key part of the antihero boom of the late 2000s.
- 7.3
- Editorial score
- #88
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2006
- Released
- 8
- Seasons
But Dexter is also one of the clearest examples of a series that ran long past its natural end. Its first four seasons are strong and sometimes excellent. The last four slide into repetition, implausibility and, finally, a conclusion that left much of its audience feeling cheated.
Its opening credits, which turn a morning routine into a series of violent-looking close-ups, are among the best of the era.
Story
The show's structure is simple and initially very effective. Each season introduces a new threat: a rival killer, a suspicious colleague, an investigation that edges too close. The first season's hunt for a killer who seems to be communicating with Dexter personally is tightly plotted, and the second, in which Dexter's own victims are discovered, raises the pressure superbly. The fourth season, which pits Dexter against a seemingly ordinary family man with a long history of murder, is widely considered the series' peak and ends with genuine shock.
After that, the formula shows its strain. New antagonists arrive with less menace, the police department's failure to notice what is under its nose becomes increasingly hard to accept, and storylines are resolved in ways that avoid real consequences. The final season, in particular, is poorly paced and was so unpopular that a later revival series was conceived in part to offer a different ending.

Characters and performances
Michael C. Hall is the reason to watch. His Dexter is controlled, funny in voiceover and quietly unsettling, and Hall conveys the effort it takes the character to imitate normal human feeling. Jennifer Carpenter's Debra, profane and fiercely loyal, is the emotional heart of the series. James Remar appears throughout as Dexter's father, Harry, in flashbacks and visions that dramatise the killer's code. John Lithgow's guest turn in the fourth season is outstanding, and Erik King's permanently suspicious Sergeant Doakes provides the early seasons with a superb foil. Many other colleagues, however, are defined by one-note subplots.
Craft
The show makes clever use of its setting, contrasting bright Miami sunshine with the plastic-wrapped rooms where Dexter works. Its opening credits, which turn a morning routine into a series of violent-looking close-ups, are among the best of the era. Later seasons feel more workmanlike, with flatter direction and an over-reliance on narration to explain motives.
Who it is for
Fans of crime drama and antihero stories will enjoy the early seasons enormously. Newcomers could reasonably treat the fourth season as a natural stopping point. The violence is frequent, though often more suggested than shown.
What works
- Michael C. Hall makes a killer's inner monologue darkly compelling
- The fourth season, with John Lithgow, is gripping antihero drama
- Jennifer Carpenter's Debra gives the show raw emotional stakes
- Early seasons build smart cat-and-mouse tension in the police station
What doesn’t
- Later seasons repeat the villain-of-the-year formula with diminishing returns
- The original finale is widely regarded as one of television's worst
- Supporting detectives rarely develop beyond procedural roles
Head to head
- Craft
- 7.39.6
- Story
- 6.89.7
- Characters
- 7.49.6
- Performances
- 8.49.8
Breaking Bad edges it by 2.4. See them side by side
The verdict
Dexter scores 7.3 as a whole: its best seasons deserve considerably more, thanks to Hall's defining performance and some excellent plotting, but the steep decline in its second half and a notoriously weak finale drag the complete series down. It remains an influential, often thrilling show that is best remembered selectively.





