Barry · 2018
Barry: a hitman comedy that turned, brilliantly, into a study of guilt
Our review of Barry, Bill Hader and Alec Berg's HBO series: a dark comedy that grew into a bleak, formally daring drama about violence and self-deception.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Barry sounds like a sketch premise: a hitman who wants to be an actor. For its first season, it plays that joke beautifully, finding comedy in the gap between Barry's lethal competence and his wooden attempts to express emotion on stage. But Bill Hader and Alec Berg were never content with a single gag. Over four seasons, the series grew darker, stranger and more ambitious, becoming a serious and often painful examination of whether a person who has done terrible things can ever be good.
- 8.7
- Editorial score
- #29
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2018
- Released
- 4
- Seasons
Not every viewer followed it all the way. The final season in particular sacrifices laughs for despair. Yet the show's willingness to change is exactly what makes it one of the most distinctive HBO series of its time.
Yet the show's willingness to change is exactly what makes it one of the most distinctive HBO series of its time.
Story and themes
The early episodes balance satire of Los Angeles acting culture with crime-comedy mechanics, and the balance is precise. Gene Cousineau's class, full of hopefuls reciting scenes badly, is a gift for comic writing, while Barry's criminal life keeps intruding in increasingly violent ways. As the show continues, the question of accountability moves to the centre. Characters who once seemed like comic relief carry real trauma, and the series refuses to let Barry's charm excuse what he has done.
The later seasons can feel punishing, and a bold structural choice in the final run divided audiences. Some developments arrive with too little set-up. But the writers' commitment to the idea that violence ripples outward, damaging everyone it touches, gives the series an integrity many crime dramas lack.

Characters and performances
Hader is excellent as Barry, particularly in moments where a blank, affable face slips to reveal rage or emptiness. Henry Winkler, as the vain but ultimately human Cousineau, gives a performance of wonderful range, and Sarah Goldberg makes Sally a fascinating, often infuriating portrait of ambition and self-protection. Stephen Root is quietly monstrous as Fuches. Anthony Carrigan's NoHo Hank, a cheerful Chechen gangster with impeccable manners, is one of the great comic creations of the decade, and the show gives him unexpected emotional depth.
Direction and craft
The series is at its most surprising as filmmaking. Hader directed a large share of the episodes, and his style evolves from tidy sitcom framing to wide, carefully blocked compositions that let violence erupt suddenly in the frame. The second-season episode ronny/lily, in which a routine job turns into a surreal fight with a martial-arts prodigy, is a showcase of comic timing and visual invention. A motorcycle chase in the third season is similarly thrilling. The episodes are short, and they are edited without a wasted moment.
Who it is for
Viewers who like their comedy dark will find the first two seasons irresistible. Those who stay for the later seasons should expect a shift towards tragedy. Anyone interested in how television directing can evolve over the life of a show will find Barry especially rewarding.
What works
- Bill Hader's direction grows startlingly confident and inventive
- Henry Winkler and Anthony Carrigan give unforgettable performances
- The second-season episode ronny/lily is a comic action masterpiece
- Takes the consequences of violence more seriously than most dramas
What doesn’t
- The final season's bleakness squeezes out much of the humour
- Some late plot turns feel abrupt rather than fully built
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.27.0
- Story
- 8.56.2
- Characters
- 8.96.4
- Performances
- 9.36.9
Barry edges it by 2.3. See them side by side
The verdict
Barry earns an 8.7 for outstanding performances, directing that grows more inventive with every season, and the seriousness with which it treats its central moral question. The final season's relentless gloom and a few rushed turns keep it from the very top rank, but few comedies have ever evolved so fearlessly into something so much deeper.





