Skip to content
Anime reviewGood

Black Clover · 2017

Black Clover: a loud, earnest shonen that earns its stamina the hard way

Black Clover review: Studio Pierrot's 170-episode fantasy starts grating and generic, then grows into a warm, energetic battle series with a lovable squad.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Ignacio Pineda3 min read

Good

Editorial score out of 10

Black Clover has a reputation problem, and it is partly self-inflicted. Its opening episodes are loud, derivative and centred on a protagonist whose volume seems permanently set to maximum, which led many viewers to drop it early. Those who persisted tend to describe a different show a few dozen episodes later: still unmistakably a traditional battle shonen, but warmer, sharper and far more fun.

7.2
Editorial score
#87
Of 93 anime reviewed
2017
Released
170
Episodes

It is not a series that reinvents the genre. It is one that commits to its conventions so sincerely that its best stretches become hard to resist.

Viewers who enjoy long-form battle shonen with a big cast and a sincere, feel-good tone will find a lot to like.

Story

The premise combines the hardworking-underdog formula with a magical-knight fantasy. What distinguishes it is the class system: nobles look down on commoners, and commoners on the peasants of the kingdom's edge, and Asta's lack of magic makes him the lowest of the low. That social friction gives his ambition a political edge that develops as the series introduces rival kingdoms, internal corruption and a darker threat behind recent attacks.

The structure is episodic and arc-based, with training, tournaments and invasions following a familiar rhythm. A long run of mostly standalone material slows momentum, and the anime concluded its television run before adapting the manga's later arcs, leaving the story unfinished on screen. A feature film followed, but it does not carry the main plot forward.

Black Clover
Black Cloveravex pictures

Characters

Asta is the show's greatest strength and weakness. His relentless optimism and refusal to give up are infectious once the writing gives him more texture, but the early screaming is grating. Yuno is initially aloof and underwritten. The ensemble is where the show shines: the Black Bulls, led by the laconic, frighteningly strong captain Yami, include a hot-headed brawler, a gluttonous cotton-magic user, a painfully awkward poison mage and a royal who cannot control her own power, and their bickering camaraderie gives the series its heart. Noelle's growth in particular is handled well.

Watch
Black Clover — trailer

Animation and sound

Studio Pierrot's animation is inconsistent in a way common to long-running weekly productions. Many ordinary episodes are stiff, with limited movement and off-model faces, but the studio clearly reserves resources for major fights, some of which are dynamic, colourful and impressively choreographed. Magic effects and the design of the grimoires give battles visual variety.

The soundtrack is energetic and does its job, and the show cycled through a large number of opening and ending songs, several of which became fan favourites. The Japanese voice performance for Asta was the target of much early criticism, though it softens as the series finds its footing.

Gallery · 3 imagesavex pictures · Crunchyroll

Who it is for

Viewers who enjoy long-form battle shonen with a big cast and a sincere, feel-good tone will find a lot to like. Anyone wanting subversion, tight plotting or consistently high production values should look elsewhere. Newcomers should be prepared to give it more than a handful of episodes before judging it.

What works

  • The Black Bulls are an endearing found family full of distinct personalities
  • Class prejudice gives Asta's underdog story more bite than usual
  • Later arcs deliver genuinely exciting, well-choreographed fights
  • A consistently upbeat tone makes it an easy series to binge

What doesn’t

  • Asta's constant yelling in early episodes is a real barrier to entry
  • Leans on familiar shonen tropes, rivalries and power-ups for long stretches
  • Weekly production leads to uneven animation and filler-heavy pacing

Head to head

Sound
7.48.8
Story
6.87.1
Animation
6.99.7
Characters
7.67.8

Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba edges it by 0.8. See them side by side

GoodHow we score

The verdict

Black Clover is a good but uneven series whose reception improved markedly as it went on. Its lovable ensemble, rousing fights and underdog energy are real pleasures, while its grating start, formulaic arcs and variable animation are equally real problems. A 7.2 recognises a series that works hard for its fans without rising above its genre.

Quick answers

Is Black Clover worth watching?

Voxizer scores Black Clover (2017) 7.2 out of 10 — good. Black Clover is a good but uneven series whose reception improved markedly as it went on. Its lovable ensemble, rousing fights and underdog energy are real pleasures, while its grating start, formulaic arcs and variable animation are equally real problems.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Black Clover yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for anime: Ignacio Pineda.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.