Skip to content
Comic reviewGood

Black Science · 2013

Black Science is a breathless multiverse ride dragged down by its miserable hero

Black Science sends Rick Remender and Matteo Scalera's broken scientist through wild parallel worlds, with superb art and a relentlessly grim tone.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán3 min read

Good

Editorial score out of 10

Black Science starts like a cannon shot. The first issue drops readers into a jungle war in a stranger reality, already mid-disaster, and Matteo Scalera's pages barely pause for breath from there. As pure spectacle, it is one of the most visually thrilling Image books of the 2010s.

7.2
Editorial score
#52
Of 53 comics reviewed
2013
Released
43
Issues

The harder question is whether it is worth spending six years' worth of comics with Grant McKay. Rick Remender builds the series around a brilliant, selfish man confronting the damage he has done, and the more the book commits to that, the more its energy curdles into gloom.

His storytelling in action sequences is superb, with wide panels that sell scale and quick cuts that sell panic.

A multiverse without brakes

The premise is a strong engine. The Pillar jumps on a timer, the team cannot choose where they land, and each new reality is a chance for Remender and Scalera to invent something outlandish. Early arcs deliver fish-people at war with frog-people, a Native American techno-civilisation that never met European colonisers, and versions of Earth bent by religion or disease. The sabotage mystery and the corporate tension within the group add a thriller spine.

As the series continues, the scope widens into a larger conflict between versions of Grant and the anarchist scientists who share his ideas. That expansion gives the series its thematic payoff but also makes the middle arcs repetitive, as the cast lurch from captivity to escape to catastrophe in a cycle that begins to feel familiar.

Black Science
Black ScienceEdition cover via Open Library

Scalera's pages

Scalera is the book's star. His figures are loose, angular and in constant motion, and he draws creatures, machinery and ruined cities with a fluid scratchiness that suits a story about losing control. Colourists Dean White and later Moreno Dinisio give each dimension a distinct identity, from sickly greens to burning oranges, which helps readers orient themselves when the setting changes every few issues.

His storytelling in action sequences is superb, with wide panels that sell scale and quick cuts that sell panic. Even the weakest arcs remain a pleasure to look at.

Living with Grant McKay

Remender's scripts lean on heavy caption narration from inside Grant's head, most of it guilt, rage and self-justification. The intent is clear: this is a story about a man whose ego broke his family and many worlds besides. But Grant's voice rarely changes register, and his children, Pia and Nate, along with colleagues such as Kadir and Rebecca, too often exist to suffer the consequences of his choices rather than to drive the plot themselves. Characters are removed abruptly, and the shock value diminishes with repetition.

When the series slows down for its later, more reflective material, it finds moments of tenderness. They arrive late, and some readers will have lost patience by then.

Who it is for

Readers who love dense, violent pulp science fiction and are drawn to Remender's other creator-owned work, such as Low or Deadly Class, will find a lot here. Anyone who needs a sympathetic lead, or who tires of unremitting bleakness, should sample the first collection before committing.

What works

  • Matteo Scalera's kinetic, scratchy art makes every alien world feel dangerous
  • Inventive dimensional set pieces, from frog-men wars to techno-shamanic America
  • Opens at full sprint with genuine stakes for the whole expedition
  • Moreno Dinisio and Dean White's colours give each reality its own palette

What doesn’t

  • Grant McKay's self-pity and narration become exhausting over 43 issues
  • The middle stretch loops through similar crises and loses focus
  • Supporting cast are often thin and treated as disposable

Head to head

Art
8.99.2
Story
6.88.7
Pacing
6.97.8
Characters
6.69.3

Saga edges it by 1.6. See them side by side

GoodHow we score

The verdict

Black Science has thrilling art, a brilliant concept and a handful of unforgettable worlds. It is undercut by a narrator who is hard to spend time with, a cast that rarely gets room to grow and a long middle that spins its wheels. A 7.2 recognises a good, often exhilarating series whose emotional arc does not match its imagination.

Quick answers

Is Black Science worth reading?

Voxizer scores Black Science (2013) 7.2 out of 10 — good. Black Science has thrilling art, a brilliant concept and a handful of unforgettable worlds. It is undercut by a narrator who is hard to spend time with, a cast that rarely gets room to grow and a long middle that spins its wheels.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Black Science yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for comics: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.