Skip to content
Comic reviewEssential#3 in comics

All-Star Superman · 2005

All-Star Superman: the kindest superhero comic ever made, and one of the strangest

All-Star Superman review. Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely give a dying Superman twelve issues of Silver Age invention, and make kindness the real superpower.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán9 min read

Essential

Editorial score out of 10

Most Superman stories try to make him relatable by making him suffer. All-Star Superman makes him dying instead, and then spends twelve issues showing what a decent person does with the time left. The answer, according to Grant Morrison and Frank Quitely, is mostly to be kind: to Lois, to Jimmy, to strangers on rooftops, and even, in a way that keeps the series interesting, to Lex Luthor. It is a comic about the most powerful being on Earth that finds its drama in his manners.

9.4
Editorial score
#3
Of 53 comics reviewed
2005
Released
9.7
Best at: Art

That sounds sentimental, and in places it is. But the book is also full of ideas pitched at the speed of a Saturday-morning serial: sun-eaters, time-travelling Supermen, a bottled Kryptonian city, a Bizarro world that runs on backwards logic. Morrison takes the gaudiest material from Superman's long history and plays it straight, and Quitely draws it so carefully that it reads as myth rather than camp. We think it is the best Superman story in print, and one of the few superhero comics that a reader with no interest in superheroes can be handed without apology.

The premise

The first issue opens with a single page that tells the origin in four panels and eight words, and then moves on. Superman is called to rescue a crewed expedition to the Sun, organised by the scientist Leo Quintum and sabotaged by Lex Luthor. He saves everyone. The cost is a dose of solar radiation large enough to supercharge his body and, slowly, to burn it out. Quintum's diagnosis is delivered without melodrama, and it sets the clock that runs under everything afterwards.

Apoptosis has begun. Cell death.

— Leo Quintum, All-Star Superman #1

What Morrison does next is the surprise. The book does not become a race for a cure. Superman tells Lois who he is, takes her to the Fortress of Solitude for her birthday, and gives her his powers for a day. He has a year, and he chooses to spend it settling accounts and doing small favours on a large scale. The countdown is felt rather than announced. That restraint is what lets the series carry so much invention without falling apart: underneath the giants and the robots, there is always a man putting his affairs in order.

All-Star Superman
All-Star SupermanInterior page from All-Star Superman #1 by Grant Morrison, Frank Quitely and Jamie Grant — DC Comics, via DC

The writing

Morrison's method here is compression. Each issue contains what an ordinary monthly would spread over six, and the dialogue does a great deal in very few words. A scene in which Clark Kent visits Luthor in prison for an interview runs on two levels at once: Luthor ranting about Superman to the one man he cannot see clearly, and Clark quietly rescuing him from a riot without ever dropping the disguise. It is funny, tense and sad in the same few pages, and the joke depends on the reader knowing more than Luthor does.

The series was conceived as a timeless version of the character, outside the regular DC continuity, and the writing leans hard into that freedom. There is no crossover to service and no recent event to recap. Morrison pulls in the Silver Age's strangest inventions, the Superman Squad, the bottle city of Kandor, the Bizarros, and treats them as a natural part of a mythic world. The book never pauses to apologise for the strangeness, which is the right instinct; it asks readers to accept a sun-powered man in a cape, so a few extra wonders hardly strain the deal.

  1. 1998

    Morrison and colleagues pitch Superman Now, an unmade revamp whose ideas feed the later series

  2. 2005

    The first issue appears in November under DC's All Star line, outside the main continuity

  3. 2007

    The first six issues are collected in a hardcover volume

  4. 2008

    The twelfth and final issue is published in October

  5. 2010

    Absolute All-Star Superman collects the run in an oversized edition with extras

  6. 2011

    An animated film adaptation is released, and DC issues the complete story as one paperback

  7. 2025

    DC and Penguin Random House Audio release a full-cast audiobook adaptation

The art

Frank Quitely is the reason the book looks like nothing else on the shelf. His Superman is broad and heavy, closer to a farmhand than a bodybuilder, and he moves with an ease that suggests nothing in the world can hurt him. His Clark Kent is the same body folded inward: hunched, apologetic, a size too big for his clothes and forever tripping over things. In most versions the disguise is a running joke about how nobody notices. Here, through posture alone, it is plausible, and the physical comedy of Clark blundering through the Daily Planet while quietly saving everyone around him is the best visual gag in the series.

Jamie Grant's digital inks and colours give the pages their texture. The line is soft, the colours are graded like a sunset, and the light always seems to be falling on Superman from a little above. It suits a story about a man literally overcharged with sunlight. The page layouts are conservative, mostly grids, which leaves the big moments room: the first issue's cover, Superman simply sitting on a cloud above Metropolis, carries more emotion than most splash pages.

How it reads

Accessibility
7/10
Rewards some knowledge of Superman, never demands it
Idea density
9.5/10
A new concept every few pages
Emotional weight
9/10
Quiet, cumulative, and aimed squarely at the reader
Art consistency
9.5/10
One art team for the entire run
Standalone issues
8.5/10
Most chapters close their own story
Gallery · 3 imagesInterior page from All-Star Superman by Grant Morrison, Frank Quitely and Jamie Grant — DC Comics, via DC · Absolute All-Star Superman — cover art by Frank Quitely, DC Comics, 2010, via Open Library

Characters

The supporting cast gets better material than it usually does. Lois Lane is sceptical rather than starstruck, and her suspicion about the man in her life is treated as intelligence rather than an obstacle. Jimmy Olsen's issue makes him an adventurer in his own right, with a signal watch, a sense of style and real nerve. Even the Kents, in the short glimpses of Smallville, are drawn as people with their own inner lives rather than as props in an origin story.

Luthor is the one who stays with readers. Morrison writes him as a genius whose hatred of Superman is mostly envy dressed up as principle, and the series is unusually interested in what he thinks. He gets long speeches, and they are good ones: angry, self-pitying, occasionally right. The book never lets him off, but it does let him be understood, which makes him a far more frightening opponent than a villain who simply wants money or power.

Pacing and format

Twelve issues, each a complete adventure linked by the year-long countdown, is a structure that suits short reading sessions. Most chapters could be handed to someone as a one-shot. The cost is a middle stretch that drifts from the central thread, with a couple of issues that are inventive but feel less necessary than their neighbours. The original run also came out slowly, with twelve issues spread across almost three years, and some of the instalments that seemed slight at the time read better in a collection.

Collected editions
EditionContentsWorth knowing
Volume 1 hardcover (2007)Issues #1–6Half the story; the sensible place to sample
Volume 2 hardcoverIssues #7–12Completes the run
Absolute All-Star Superman (2010)Issues #1–12Oversized, slipcased, with bonus material
Complete paperback (2011)Issues #1–12304 pages; the cheapest full edition
DC Compact Comics Edition (2024)Issues #1–12Smaller trim size, priced for new readers

For most readers the single-volume paperback is the right choice, since it costs little and keeps the twelve chapters together. Anyone who cares about Quitely's line work should look at the larger formats, where the detail in the backgrounds rewards the bigger page.

Where it sits

Superhero comics of the 1980s and 1990s spent a lot of energy asking what these characters would be like in the real world, usually concluding that they would be frightening. All-Star Superman turns that question around and asks what the real world would look like if someone this decent existed in it. It is in conversation with Kingdom Come, which also cares about the old ideals, and with the archaeology of superhero history in *Planetary*, but it is warmer than either and far less interested in deconstruction.

Head to head

Art
9.79.5
Story
9.38.1
Pacing
8.67.3
Characters
9.58.0

All-Star Superman edges it by 1.1. See them side by side

Readers who come to it from darker work, such as *Watchmen*, sometimes find the earnestness hard to trust at first. It earns that trust within a couple of issues, mostly through its jokes and through the detail with which it imagines a good man's ordinary day.

For you if

  • Anyone who has never cared about Superman and wants to see why others do
  • Readers who like big ideas delivered in short, finished chapters
  • Fans of Frank Quitely's art, or of comics that look painted with light

Not for you if

  • Readers who want gritty realism or moral ambiguity from their superheroes
  • Anyone who finds dense, unexplained science-fantasy tiring rather than fun
  • Readers looking for a single continuous plot rather than linked adventures

The one remaining decision is format, and the cheapest one is also the most sensible place to begin.

What works

  • Quitely's Clark Kent is a physical comedy of slouches, so the disguise finally works
  • Every issue is a complete story, and most could stand alone as a one-shot
  • Recovers decades of Silver Age oddities without a wink or an apology
  • Luthor is written as a real rival in intellect and spite, not a scheming businessman

What doesn’t

  • The density of invented science and cameos can lose readers new to Superman's history
  • A middle stretch of issues sits more loosely to the main thread than the rest
  • The original run took nearly three years to finish, and some single issues show the gaps
EssentialHow we score

The verdict

All-Star Superman takes a character often dismissed as too powerful to be interesting and finds the interest in what he chooses to do with that power. Morrison's compressed, inventive scripts and Quitely's gentle, heavy, funny drawing make a book that reads quickly and lingers for years. The score sits just below the top tier because the middle of the run loosens its grip, and because its pleasure in Superman's history will occasionally leave a newcomer a step behind. Neither stops it from being the version of the character worth handing to anyone who asks where to start, and the rare superhero story whose final lesson is simply to be good to people.

Quick answers

Is All-Star Superman worth reading?

Voxizer scores All-Star Superman (2005) 9.4 out of 10 — essential. All-Star Superman takes a character often dismissed as too powerful to be interesting and finds the interest in what he chooses to do with that power. Morrison's compressed, inventive scripts and Quitely's gentle, heavy, funny drawing make a book that reads quickly and lingers for years.

Who will enjoy All-Star Superman?

Anyone who has never cared about Superman and wants to see why others do. Readers who like big ideas delivered in short, finished chapters. Fans of Frank Quitely's art, or of comics that look painted with light.

Who should skip All-Star Superman?

Readers who want gritty realism or moral ambiguity from their superheroes. Anyone who finds dense, unexplained science-fantasy tiring rather than fun. Readers looking for a single continuous plot rather than linked adventures.

What is All-Star Superman like, in short?

A dying Superman spends a year doing good, and the book makes that enough of a plot. Frank Quitely and Jamie Grant give the character a weight, softness and comic timing no other version has. Twelve near-standalone issues, so it reads in sittings rather than in one exhausting gulp. Luthor, Lois and Jimmy all get stories built around who they are, not around what Superman needs.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed All-Star Superman yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for comics: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.