Watchmen · 1986
Watchmen remains the superhero story that took the whole genre apart, panel by panel
Watchmen, Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons's 1986 masterpiece about masked heroes in a Cold War America, is still the most intricate and influential superhero comic.
Masterpiece
Editorial score out of 10
Watchmen is the rare comic whose reputation is fully deserved. Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons set out to examine what superheroes would really mean in the real world, and in doing so they produced a work of extraordinary formal ambition, moral seriousness and narrative intricacy. It changed how superhero stories were told and remains one of the most analysed works in the history of comics.
- 9.7
- Editorial score
- #1
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 1986
- Released
- 12
- Issues
Nearly four decades later, it still feels startlingly modern. It is not always comfortable, and its influence has been mixed, but as a single, self-contained work it remains a towering achievement.
Most chapters end with prose documents, such as memoir extracts, letters and reports, that deepen the world but slow the pace.
Who watches the watchmen
The story begins with a murder. Rorschach, an uncompromising vigilante who continues to operate despite a ban on masked heroes, investigates and becomes convinced that someone is targeting former costumed adventurers. His investigation brings him into contact with his old colleagues: the gentle, retired Nite Owl, the conflicted Silk Spectre, the brilliant businessman Ozymandias and the godlike Doctor Manhattan, whose existence has reshaped geopolitics.
Moore uses this mystery to explore the psychology of each character, examining what drives people to put on masks and what power does to those who hold it. Doctor Manhattan's chapter on Mars, in which he experiences time non-linearly, is a masterpiece of comic storytelling, and Rorschach's chapter with a prison psychiatrist is chilling. No character is simply heroic, and the story challenges readers to question their sympathies.

The grid and the pattern
Dave Gibbons's art is precise, detailed and disciplined. He uses a consistent nine-panel grid, which gives the book a steady rhythm and allows subtle variations to carry great impact. His pages are filled with recurring symbols, background details and visual echoes, including the famous smiley face, clocks and graffiti, that reward careful rereading. John Higgins's colours, with their unusual palette of purples, greens and oranges, give the book a distinctive, slightly unreal atmosphere.
Chapter five, whose pages mirror each other in their layouts, is a famous example of the book's formal complexity.
Weight and distance
Watchmen's density is both a strength and a challenge. Most chapters end with prose documents, such as memoir extracts, letters and reports, that deepen the world but slow the pace. The comic-within-a-comic, Tales of the Black Freighter, is thematically rich but can feel like a distraction on first reading.
The book's clinical construction can also create emotional distance. Its characters are fascinating, but the story's structural precision sometimes makes it feel more like an intricate machine than a lived experience. Its treatment of sexual violence, particularly a past assault and the way the story later revisits it, remains a source of debate.
Who it is for
Watchmen is essential reading for anyone interested in comics, superheroes or literature, and it was included on Time magazine's list of the best English-language novels published since 1923. It rewards patient, attentive reading and multiple revisits. Fans of the 2009 film or the 2019 television sequel will find the original far richer and more complex.
What works
- Formally dazzling structure, with symmetry and motifs repaying rereading
- Dave Gibbons's disciplined nine-panel grid is a model of clear storytelling
- Complex, psychologically rich characters with no easy heroes
- Uses superheroes to examine power, morality and Cold War fear
What doesn’t
- Prose back-matter and the pirate comic slow momentum for some readers
- Its cold, clinical construction can hold emotion at a distance
- Handling of sexual violence remains uncomfortable and debated
Head to head
- Art
- 9.69.2
- Story
- 9.88.9
- Pacing
- 9.18.8
- Characters
- 9.69.0
Watchmen edges it by 0.7. See them side by side
The verdict
Watchmen is an all-time landmark of its medium, combining formal brilliance, complex characters and profound themes into a work that still sets the standard for superhero storytelling. Its dense back-matter, emotional coolness and uncomfortable handling of sexual violence are real issues, but they do little to diminish its achievement. A 9.7 recognises one of the greatest comics ever made.




