Skip to content

Head to head

The Dark Knight Returns vs Watchmen

Watchmen takes it by 0.7, 9.7 against 9.0. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of The Dark Knight Returns
The Dark Knight Returns

1986 · Essential

  • A thunderous, operatic vision of an ageing Batman that redefined the character
  • Dense, grid-based layouts create relentless momentum
  • Its politics are muddled and easily read as endorsing authoritarian violence
Cover of Watchmen
Watchmen

1986 · Masterpiece

  • Formally dazzling structure, with symmetry and motifs repaying rereading
  • Dave Gibbons's disciplined nine-panel grid is a model of clear storytelling
  • Prose back-matter and the pirate comic slow momentum for some readers

Where the gap is

Art
9.29.6
Story
8.99.8
Pacing
8.89.1
Characters
9.09.6

At a glance

FactThe Dark Knight ReturnsWatchmen
Released1 February 19861 September 1986
WriterFrank MillerAlan Moore
PublisherDC ComicsDC Comics
Issues412
GenreSuperhero · Graphic NovelSuperhero · Graphic Novel
Artist—Dave Gibbons

The two verdicts

The Dark Knight Returns

The Dark Knight Returns still hits like a thunderclap, politics and all

The Dark Knight Returns is a ferocious, formally inventive and genuinely landmark work that redefined Batman and superhero storytelling. Its muddled politics, occasionally exhausting media segments and a legacy of grim imitators keep it from a perfect score. A 9.0 recognises an exceptional, still-powerful book that remains central to the medium's history.

Read the full review →

Watchmen

Watchmen remains the superhero story that took the whole genre apart, panel by panel

Watchmen is an all-time landmark of its medium, combining formal brilliance, complex characters and profound themes into a work that still sets the standard for superhero storytelling. Its dense back-matter, emotional coolness and uncomfortable handling of sexual violence are real issues, but they do little to diminish its achievement. A 9.7 recognises one of the greatest comics ever made.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.