Skip to content
Comic reviewExcellent

Planetary · 1998

Planetary excavates a century of pop fiction and builds a hidden history from it

Planetary, by Warren Ellis and John Cassaday, is a dazzling genre-archaeology epic about the secret history of the twentieth century, despite long delays.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor David Abellán3 min read

Excellent

Editorial score out of 10

Planetary is a love letter to the twentieth century's popular fiction, written by someone who knows every corner of it. Warren Ellis and John Cassaday use a simple procedural structure, a team investigating a strange phenomenon each issue, to explore pulp heroes, monster movies, ghost stories, spy thrillers and superhero archetypes, and to argue that all of them are pieces of one secret history.

8.8
Editorial score
#24
Of 53 comics reviewed
1998
Released
27
Issues

What begins as a series of clever genre riffs becomes an ambitious mystery about memory, power and the stories a culture tells itself. It is one of the finest achievements of late-1990s mainstream comics, even if its long gestation cost it some of its impact.

Read in a collected edition, the problem largely disappears, but the tonal shift from standalone adventures to heavy plot machinery can still feel abrupt.

Archaeologists of the impossible

Early issues are largely self-contained. The team finds an island of dead giant monsters, investigates a ghostly cop in Hong Kong, meets an aged pulp adventurer beneath a mountain and attends a London funeral that gently sends up the Vertigo horror comics of the era. Each is a smart, affectionate reinterpretation, and Ellis's dialogue is sharp and funny, particularly from the prickly Elijah Snow.

Gradually, the connecting tissue emerges. Snow, a man born in 1900 with a mysterious gift, is missing parts of his memory, and the team's investigations begin to reveal the Four, a sinister group of explorers with cosmic powers who have been hoarding the world's wonders for themselves. The idea of a secret history of the century becomes more than a conceit: it is a battle over who controls the future.

Planetary
PlanetaryEdition cover via Open Library

Cassaday's widescreen century

John Cassaday's art is essential to the series' success. His storytelling is cinematic, with wide panels and strong compositions, and he adapts his style to each genre the book visits: gritty for a wartime story, kinetic for Hong Kong action, sepia-tinted for Victorian adventure. Laura Martin's colours are just as crucial, shifting palettes to evoke different eras and moods. Together they created one of the most visually coherent series of their time.

Cassaday's character designs are striking and simple, from Snow's white suit to Jakita's black leather, and help give the team an iconic presence.

The cost of delays

The series' greatest problem was scheduling. The last several issues arrived after very long gaps, with the final issue following a lengthy wait, and that disrupted the build-up of what is otherwise a well-plotted conclusion. Read in a collected edition, the problem largely disappears, but the tonal shift from standalone adventures to heavy plot machinery can still feel abrupt.

The book also relies on genre literacy. Much of its pleasure comes from recognising the stories being reimagined, and while it remains enjoyable without that background, some of its wit and poignancy will be lost. The core characters are memorable, but they are more archetypes than fully rounded individuals.

Gallery · 3 imagesEdition cover via Open Library

Who it is for

Planetary is ideal for readers who love pulp fiction, genre history and clever mysteries, and for anyone who enjoyed Alan Moore's League of Extraordinary Gentlemen. It is best read in its collected or omnibus form, where its structure becomes clear.

What works

  • Each issue is a clever reinvention of a different pulp or genre tradition
  • John Cassaday's cinematic art gives every era its own distinctive look
  • Early standalone episodes build elegantly into a larger mystery
  • Elijah Snow's search for his lost memories is a gripping central thread

What doesn’t

  • Long publication gaps undermined the momentum of the final stretch
  • Many references land best for readers who know the source genres
  • The team's personalities are drawn more sharply than their inner lives

Head to head

Art
9.58.2
Story
8.78.7
Pacing
8.08.1
Characters
8.28.9

Planetary edges it by 0.2. See them side by side

ExcellentHow we score

The verdict

Planetary is an intelligent, gorgeously drawn and inventive series that turns genre history into a gripping story about secret power. Long delays, heavy reliance on reference and characters who remain slightly aloof keep it just short of exceptional. An 8.8 reflects an excellent series that remains one of the smartest superhero-adjacent comics ever made.

Quick answers

Is Planetary worth reading?

Voxizer scores Planetary (1998) 8.8 out of 10 — excellent. Planetary is an intelligent, gorgeously drawn and inventive series that turns genre history into a gripping story about secret power. Long delays, heavy reliance on reference and characters who remain slightly aloof keep it just short of exceptional.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Planetary yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for comics: David Abellán.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.