Skip to content

Head to head

Planetary vs Y: The Last Man

Planetary takes it by 0.2, 8.8 against 8.6. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Planetary
Planetary

1998 · Excellent

  • Each issue is a clever reinvention of a different pulp or genre tradition
  • John Cassaday's cinematic art gives every era its own distinctive look
  • Long publication gaps undermined the momentum of the final stretch
Cover of Y: The Last Man
Y: The Last Man

2002 · Excellent

  • A brilliant premise explored with wit, imagination and emotional depth
  • Yorick, 355 and Dr Mann form a compelling central trio
  • Some depictions of gender and women's groups are simplistic

Where the gap is

Art
9.58.2
Story
8.78.7
Pacing
8.08.1
Characters
8.28.9

At a glance

FactPlanetaryY: The Last Man
Released1 December 19981 September 2002
WriterWarren EllisBrian K. Vaughan
PublisherWildStormDC Comics
Issues2760
GenreAdventure · Sci-Fi · MysteryAdventure · Sci-Fi · Drama
Artist—Pia Guerra

The two verdicts

Planetary

Planetary excavates a century of pop fiction and builds a hidden history from it

Planetary is an intelligent, gorgeously drawn and inventive series that turns genre history into a gripping story about secret power. Long delays, heavy reliance on reference and characters who remain slightly aloof keep it just short of exceptional. An 8.8 reflects an excellent series that remains one of the smartest superhero-adjacent comics ever made.

Read the full review →

Y: The Last Man

Y: The Last Man turns a high-concept apocalypse into a warm, witty odyssey

Y: The Last Man is a gripping, funny and moving series that turns a provocative premise into a rich exploration of society and identity. Its dated gender politics, occasionally irritating protagonist and slower middle arcs hold it back from the very top. An 8.6 reflects an excellent, landmark series whose characters make it unforgettable.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.