Blacksad · 2000
Blacksad: the best-painted crime comic in Europe, with the cases to match
Blacksad review. Juan Díaz Canales and Juanjo Guarnido turn fifties American noir into watercolour across seven Dargaud albums, one closed case at a time.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Two Spaniards, a French publisher, an American genre and a cat. Blacksad has run on that combination since November 2000, and the animals are the least interesting thing about it. What holds the series up is that Juanjo Guarnido paints every page in watercolour, and that Juan Díaz Canales writes cases about the 1950s that would survive being drawn with human faces.
- 9.1
- Editorial score
- #10
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2000
- Released
- 9.8
- Best at: Art
There are only seven albums, spread across twenty-three years, and none of them runs much past fifty pages. That is the French album tradition doing exactly what it was built to do: hardcover, one complete case, a long wait, then another. It is also the reason the series can afford to look the way it does. Guarnido spent the nineties at Disney's Paris studio, on Hercules, Tarzan and Atlantis: The Lost Empire, and he still colours his own pages by hand.
The cost is real. A story an American publisher would give six issues gets fifty pages here, and twice the last act arrives at a sprint. One album out of the seven is a misfire. The other six are as good as crime comics get.
The premise
John Blacksad is a private investigator in an America that runs from roughly 1950 to 1959, and he is a black cat with a white muzzle. Every other character is an animal too, cast by species: the police are dogs, the fixers and hired guns tend to be reptiles, the money is often something with antlers or a beak. He served in the war, was thrown out of university inside a term, narrates in the dry first person the genre expects, and takes the jobs that come through the door because the rent is due.
The first album, Quelque part entre les ombres, opens with the murder of an actress Blacksad once guarded and later loved. What follows is the standard shape — a missing screenwriter, a beating, a commissioner who cannot pursue the case himself — handled with unusual economy. The series never pretends the shape is new. It simply executes it at a level of finish the shape rarely receives.
1990
Díaz Canales and Guarnido meet at the Lápiz Azul animation studio in Madrid
1993
Guarnido moves to Paris to animate for Disney; the project stays in letters
2000
Dargaud publishes the first album in November, after roughly seven years of work
2003
Arctic-Nation follows in March and takes the Angoulême artwork and audience prizes the next year
2023
The seventh album closes the two-part New York story begun in 2021
What that history explains is the pace. Guarnido came from animation, where a character is drawn thousands of times and has to hold together each time, and he has never worked faster than the drawing allows. Dargaud, for its part, publishes when the album is finished. Readers who arrived through monthly American comics find this maddening. It is also why there is no fill-in artist anywhere in the run.

Guarnido's watercolour
The pages are painted, not coloured. Guarnido works in transparent washes over his own line, so the light in a scene comes from the paper rather than from a gradient laid on afterwards, and each album commits to a palette: the first is black and sodium orange, the second white and grey, the third a bruised red, the fourth underwater blue, the fifth the yellow that gives Amarillo its name. The covers announce it before you open them.
The animation training shows in the acting. A cat's ears, a dog's jowls and a weasel's shoulders carry expression that human faces would need close-ups for, and Guarnido stages conversations so that the reader reads the body first. Backgrounds get the same care: a Louisiana porch, a Manhattan site office, a suburban schoolroom, all researched and all lived in rather than dressed.
Nothing in these albums is drawn twice at the same level of attention. Everything is drawn once, at the top of it.
The one criticism worth making of the art is that it is occasionally too handsome for the story it is carrying. A shakedown in an alley gets the same luminous treatment as a sunrise over the Panhandle, and the beauty can soften a scene that ought to be ugly. It is a small price, and Guarnido pays down some of it in the later albums with harder, colder light.
The seven cases
Díaz Canales does not write fifties atmosphere, he writes fifties subjects. Arctic-Nation is about a segregated neighbourhood and the two organisations feeding off it. Âme rouge puts the Red Scare, a physicist with a German past and a set of Beat poets in the same room. L'Enfer, le silence is about heroin, patent medicine and what a jazz musician's manager takes from him. The last two albums are about a builder remaking New York and the unions standing in the road.
That is the series' real argument: the animals let a European writer approach American history at an angle, without the flattery or the reverence a human cast would invite. The politics are specific, researched and never resolved with a speech.
| Album | French release | The verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Quelque part entre les ombres | November 2000 | The genre done straight, and done beautifully; still the cleanest way in |
| 2. Arctic-Nation | March 2003 | The best script of the run, and the one with the coldest ending |
| 3. Âme rouge | November 2005 | Ambitious, crowded, and the closest the series gets to a novel |
| 4. L'Enfer, le silence | September 2010 | One New Orleans night in flashback; the most controlled album |
| 5. Amarillo | November 2013 | Gorgeous and slack; a road movie where a case should be |
| 6. Alors, tout tombe — Première partie | October 2021 | The return, and a city drawn from the girders down |
| 7. Alors, tout tombe — Seconde partie | November 2023 | A satisfying close, hurried in its final quarter |
Amarillo is the one to be honest about. It sends Blacksad after a stolen car and lets two Beat writers take over the book, and the detective spends much of it watching other people's story happen. The drawing is among Guarnido's finest. The case is barely a case.
Animals as casting
The species conceit could have been a one-note joke and is not, because it is used as casting rather than as allegory. Dogs are police because police work is a pack trade; a cane toad tycoon is repellent in a way a human actor would have to work at; the weasel reporter Weekly is small, quick, unclean and welcome everywhere. This is closer to how a film director fills a supporting cast than to the national allegory of Maus.
It has limits, and the series runs into them. Species shorthand can flatten a character into their type, and Arctic-Nation is doing something deliberately uncomfortable when it maps a racial conflict onto fur colour — the album knows it, and mostly earns it, but it is the one readers argue about. Blacksad himself is thinly written by design: laconic, decent, permanently alone, a lens more than a man.
How it reads
- Art
- 10/10
- Painted throughout; no assistant, no dip
- Case density
- 8/10
- Real plots, compressed into fifty pages
- Welcome to newcomers
- 9/10
- Self-contained albums and a familiar genre shape
- Violence
- 7/10
- Sudden and consequential rather than dwelt upon
Weekly is the counterweight, and the reason the run has warmth as well as polish. He arrives in the second album, talks too much, smells appalling and gets Blacksad into rooms he could not otherwise enter. A 2025 spin-off album, drawn by Giovanni Rigano rather than Guarnido, went back to his youth for the series' twenty-fifth anniversary.
Where to start
Anywhere, honestly. Every album closes its own case and the recurring cast is three people deep. The tidiest entry is the first album, because it is short and it shows the method; the strongest is Arctic-Nation; the most impressive single piece of construction is L'Enfer, le silence, which runs one night in New Orleans and cuts backwards through it.
In English, the history is messy: an American publisher folded mid-series, and it was 2010 before Dark Horse gathered the first three albums into one volume. Buy the collected editions rather than hunting the early paperbacks. The nearest thing on an English-language shelf is Frank Miller's black-and-white noir, and the contrast is instructive.
Head to head
- Art
- 9.89.5
- Story
- 8.67.4
- Pacing
- 8.58.2
- Characters
- 8.97.3
Blacksad edges it by 1.1. See them side by side
Sin City is the louder book and the more stylised, built out of high-contrast blacks and men who narrate their own beatings; Blacksad is the quieter, more classical one, and its violence costs something. Readers who liked the period research of From Hell will recognise the instinct, without the density.
For you if
- Anyone who reads comics for the drawing and will stop on a page
- Readers who want detective fiction with real fifties politics under it
- People who would rather have seven finished albums than seventy issues
Not for you if
- Anyone who wants a long serial with an arc to follow
- Readers who find talking animals a barrier in a serious story
- Anyone hoping for a case that runs longer than fifty pages
If that sounds right, the publisher's own series page is the cleanest map of what exists in French, including the two-part edition of the New York story.
What works
- Guarnido paints and colours every page, and the standard has not slipped
- Real fifties subjects: segregation, the Red Scare, heroin, city contracts
- Every album closes its own case, so there is no wrong place to begin
- Species casting that tells you who someone is before they open their mouth
What doesn’t
- Amarillo swaps a case for a road trip and the plot goes slack
- Eight years separate the fifth album from the sixth
- Fifty-odd pages an album; two of the endings arrive at a sprint
The verdict
Blacksad is the rare series where the craft on the page and the thinking behind it are running at the same level. Guarnido has painted twenty-three years of albums without an assistant and without a visible dip, and Díaz Canales has used them for fifties American subjects that a human cast would make either sanctimonious or nostalgic. The score stops short of the top for two reasons: Amarillo mistakes a road trip for a case, and the album format occasionally forces a conclusion into five pages that needed fifteen. Neither undoes what the other six achieve. For anyone who has ever wanted detective fiction drawn at the standard of a gallery wall, this is the series.




