Bloodborne · 2015
Bloodborne is FromSoftware's most focused, feverish and aggressive nightmare
Bloodborne review: FromSoftware's gothic PS4 action RPG rewards aggression with superb combat and a haunting Yharnam, though its tech has aged badly.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Bloodborne took FromSoftware's Souls formula and deliberately removed the safety blanket. There is no shield to hide behind and very little reason to back away. What replaces caution is momentum: a fast, predatory combat system that rewards stepping in rather than stepping back, set in a city whose horrors grow stranger the longer one looks at them.
- 9.3
- Editorial score
- #16
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2015
- Released
- 9.6
- Best at: Gameplay
It remains the studio's most tightly focused game, and for many players its best. Its only serious shortcomings concern technology and some optional content rather than its core design.
The Old Hunters expansion, on the other hand, is superb, adding some of the most demanding and memorable encounters in the game.
How it plays
The hunter carries a trick weapon in one hand and a firearm in the other. Trick weapons transform mid-combo, so a cleaver becomes a longer saw, a cane becomes a whip, and a heavy hammer conceals a sword. Firearms serve less as damage and more as a parry tool: a well-timed shot staggers an enemy, opening them up for a devastating visceral attack.
The key innovation is the Rally system. After taking damage, a portion of lost health can be regained by striking back quickly. This small rule transforms behaviour, pushing players to answer aggression with aggression. Dodges are quick sidesteps rather than rolls, and battles feel like frantic duels.
Boss fights are fierce and varied, from towering beasts to elegant hunters, and several are among the most celebrated in FromSoftware's catalogue. The main limitation is breadth: magic-style builds are much less developed than in the Souls series, and the weapon roster, while excellent, is smaller.

World and story
Yharnam is a masterpiece of level design. Its streets loop back on themselves, ladders and gates create shortcuts, and the city's gothic architecture gradually gives way to far more otherworldly places. The story begins as a werewolf-hunting nightmare and slides steadily into cosmic horror, told through item descriptions, fragments of dialogue and environmental detail.
The Chalice Dungeons offer additional challenge through randomised layouts, but their repetitive corridors and recycled enemies pale beside the handcrafted main world. The Old Hunters expansion, on the other hand, is superb, adding some of the most demanding and memorable encounters in the game.
Presentation
Art direction is magnificent. Victorian spires, candlelit alleys, fog and moonlight create one of the most striking settings of its generation, and creature design is unsettlingly inventive. The orchestral and choral score gives boss fights a grand, tragic weight.
Technically, Bloodborne has aged less well. It targets a low frame rate with inconsistent frame pacing, and loading times were a notable complaint at launch. Its long absence from newer hardware beyond backwards compatibility has become a frequent frustration among fans.
Who it is for
This is essential for fans of FromSoftware and anyone who enjoys demanding, skill-based combat. Its insistence on aggression can make it harsher for newcomers early on than some of the studio's later, more flexible games. It is also a strong pick for players drawn to gothic and cosmic horror, since few games handle atmosphere this confidently.
What works
- Rally system turns every fight into a deliberate act of aggression
- Trick weapons are inventive, flexible and a pleasure to master
- Yharnam's intricate, interlinked streets reward exploration
- The Old Hunters expansion ranks among the studio's finest work
What doesn’t
- Uneven frame pacing and the lack of a modern update hurt it today
- Chalice Dungeons are repetitive and far weaker than the main world
- Build variety is narrower than in the Souls games
Head to head
- Story
- 9.08.3
- Gameplay
- 9.69.2
- Longevity
- 8.88.9
- Presentation
- 9.28.9
Bloodborne edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Bloodborne earns an exceptional score for its peerless combat design, brilliant world and deeply unsettling atmosphere. Technical limitations, weak optional dungeons and narrower build variety keep it just below all-time landmark status, but as a distilled expression of what FromSoftware does best, it remains extraordinary.





