Chinatown · 1974
Chinatown: a detective story where the crime is the city's plumbing
Chinatown review. Roman Polanski and Robert Towne's 1974 neo-noir turns a divorce job in drought-era Los Angeles into a story of water, land and power.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Most detective films hide a body. Chinatown hides a reservoir. Robert Towne's script takes the oldest set-up in private-eye fiction, a cheap divorce job that turns out to be something else, and points it at the least glamorous subject imaginable: who gets the water in a city built on a desert. The result is a mystery whose clues are irrigation ditches, county records and the price of orange groves, and it is more gripping for it.
- 9.4
- Editorial score
- #9
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 1974
- Released
- 9.8
- Best at: Story
Fifty years on, it still plays as a near-perfect machine. Roman Polanski's direction is patient where it could have been flashy, Jack Nicholson gives the performance that fixed his screen persona for a decade, and the film's view of power, that the people who own a city do not need to break its laws because they write them, has not dated at all. The reservations are about pace and about context, not about craft.
The premise
Los Angeles, 1937, in a drought. J. J. Gittes runs a comfortable business photographing unfaithful spouses, and he is good at it: well dressed, well paid, a little vain about both. A woman calling herself Mrs Mulwray hires him to follow her husband, Hollis, the chief engineer of the city's water department. Gittes gets his photographs, the photographs reach the newspapers, and then a second Mrs Mulwray walks into his office with a lawyer and a lawsuit. Someone has used him, and Gittes takes that personally.
That is the first act, and it is all a newcomer needs. What follows is an investigation that keeps widening. Water is being dumped at night while the city goes thirsty. Farmland in the valley is changing hands. A dam is being argued over in council. Gittes keeps asking who benefits, and the film keeps answering with a bigger name than he expected. The case is never really about adultery, and the joy of the first hour is watching him realise it a few steps after the audience begins to suspect it.

The script
Towne wrote Gittes for Nicholson, and he built the story out of real Los Angeles history. The city's aqueduct, opened in 1913, brought water from the Owens Valley more than two hundred miles away, and the land deals around it made fortunes for people who knew in advance where the water would go. Chinatown moves those events forward a generation and fictionalises them freely, but the shape is real: a public project that enriches a private few, sold to the public as necessity.
1913
The Los Angeles Aqueduct opens, carrying Owens Valley water to the city
1928
The St. Francis Dam collapses, a disaster the film alludes to
1937
The year the story is set, during an invented drought
1973
Principal photography begins in October, with Polanski directing
1974
Released in the United States on 20 June
1991
Selected for the United States National Film Registry
The draft Towne delivered was, by most accounts, far longer than the finished film and came with a narration by Gittes. Polanski cut the voice-over and reordered scenes so that the audience and the detective uncover each fact at the same moment. That decision is the backbone of the film. Gittes is present in almost every scene, and the camera rarely knows more than he does; when he is knocked out, the film cuts to black with him. Information arrives in a deed register, a typed obituary column, a single overheard word, and nothing is repeated for the inattentive.
The title itself is a riddle the script declines to solve early. Towne took it from a police officer who had worked the district and believed the best thing a cop could do there was nothing, because no one could tell whether intervening helped or harmed. Gittes once worked there too, and the film treats the place less as a neighbourhood than as a state of mind: somewhere good intentions go to make things worse.
"What did you do in Chinatown?" "As little as possible."
Direction
Polanski had not wanted to return to Los Angeles; it was a few years since the murder of his wife, Sharon Tate, in the city. He was persuaded by the script, and his outsider's eye is all over the film. This is a Los Angeles of white light and dry riverbeds rather than rain-slicked night streets. The noir is in the sunshine. Crimes happen at noon on country roads, and one of its most menacing scenes is a polite lunch over grilled fish.
He frames with restraint. Long takes follow Gittes into rooms where the audience, like him, has to read the furniture for clues. Close-ups are saved for faces that are hiding something, which is most of them. Polanski also appears on screen, briefly, as a small hoodlum with a knife, and the sequence that gives Gittes his famous bandaged nose is staged with a nasty, matter-of-fact speed that sets the tone for everything after it.
The famous dispute between writer and director was over the ending: Towne wanted one thing, Polanski insisted on another, and Polanski's version is the one on screen. There is no need to say more than that, except that the film's final minutes are why people still argue about it, and that going in unspoiled is worth some effort.
Performances
Nicholson plays Gittes as a man with more vanity than cynicism. He cares about his suits, his reputation and his jokes, and the comedy of the early scenes, a smutty story told too loudly, a temper lost over a newspaper photograph, gives the darker later stretches a person to happen to. With his nose bandaged for much of the running time, he has to act with half a face, and he makes the bandage part of the character's wounded pride.
Faye Dunaway's Evelyn Mulwray is built from hesitations. She stammers on certain words, lights cigarettes she does not finish, and answers questions a beat too precisely. The script initially presents her as the noir femme fatale, and Dunaway plays that surface while signalling, in small ways, that something else is underneath it. John Huston, director of The Maltese Falcon a generation earlier, plays Noah Cross with grandfatherly charm and a habit of mispronouncing Gittes's name. It is one of the great screen villains, and almost all of it is good manners. The smaller parts, John Hillerman's prim water official and Burt Young's aggrieved fisherman among them, are cast with the same care.
Craft
John A. Alonzo, brought on a few weeks into production, shot the film in Panavision with natural-looking light, and its palette of sun-bleached stucco, dust and pale linen suits is as specific as any colour film of its decade. Richard Sylbert's production design keeps the period quiet: the 1930s are there in the cars and the telephones, never in a museum-like display.
Jerry Goldsmith's score was written and recorded in about ten days after an earlier score was rejected, and it sounds nothing like a rush job. A solo trumpet carries the main theme over strings, harps and an unsettling prepared piano, and it does the emotional work the cut narration would have done: lonely, romantic and faintly sordid at once.
How it asks to be watched
- Attention required
- 9/10
- Names, deeds and places matter; phones down
- Pace
- 4/10
- Deliberate procedural rhythm, especially in the middle hour
- Violence
- 5/10
- Sparse and sudden rather than constant
- Rewatch value
- 9/10
- Second viewings reveal how much is planted early
Where it sits
Chinatown arrived at the height of the New Hollywood, when studio money backed directors with personal visions, and it remains one of the period's defining films. It took eleven Academy Award nominations and won for Towne's screenplay. A sequel, The Two Jakes, directed by Nicholson from Towne's script, followed in 1990 and was not well received; a planned third film was never made.
Its influence is easiest to see in later films about American wealth built on a natural resource. *There Will Be Blood* swaps water for oil and the detective for the tycoon, but it shares the conviction that the founding fortunes of the West were dug out of somebody else's land. Both films treat greed as civic history rather than personal failing.
The other obvious descendant is Blade Runner, which carried the Los Angeles detective story into the future and kept its moral fog. Where Ridley Scott's film is all rain and neon, Chinatown is dust and daylight, and its corruption is a matter of public record rather than science fiction.
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.310.0
- Story
- 9.88.6
- Direction
- 9.59.5
- Performances
- 9.48.8
Chinatown edges it by 0.1. See them side by side
For a very different film about memory and how cinema stores a life, Millennium Actress makes an unexpected companion piece: another story in which an outsider follows a woman through a past he only half understands.
For you if
- Anyone who likes mysteries built from evidence rather than coincidence
- Viewers interested in how cities are actually governed and who profits
- Fans of 1970s American film and of performances that hold back
Not for you if
- Viewers who want a quick pace and frequent action
- Anyone who cannot watch work by Roman Polanski in light of his conviction
- Those who want a mystery that ties itself up neatly by the credits
The best way in is the plainest one: a quiet evening, full attention, and no plot summaries beyond the first act.
What works
- A plot where every clue is about water, land and money rather than a missing gun
- Nicholson's Gittes is in nearly every scene, so the audience learns only what he learns
- Huston's Noah Cross makes courtesy more frightening than any threat
- Goldsmith's trumpet theme does the work a voice-over narration would have done
What doesn’t
- The middle hour is dense with deeds, maps and names; inattention is punished
- Its slow, procedural rhythm can feel airless to viewers raised on faster thrillers
- The director's later criminal case makes the film hard for some to watch at all
The verdict
Chinatown earns its reputation through precision. Every scene carries information, every performance is pitched to the scale of the room, and the script's choice of subject, water rights in place of jewels or a dead partner, gives the genre a weight it rarely carries. It is held just short of the very top tier because its middle stretch asks a great deal of a modern viewer's patience, and because its density can leave a first-time audience a step behind rather than pleasurably so. Those are small costs. As a piece of storytelling about how power works in a modern city, very few films have matched it in the half-century since.





