Skip to content

Head to head

Blade Runner vs Chinatown

Chinatown takes it by 0.1, 9.4 against 9.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Blade Runner
Blade Runner

1982 · Essential

  • Its dense, lived-in vision of Los Angeles remains unsurpassed
  • Rutger Hauer makes Roy Batty tragic, frightening and unforgettable
  • The plot is slow and thin by thriller standards
Cover of Chinatown
Chinatown

1974 · Essential

  • A plot where every clue is about water, land and money rather than a missing gun
  • Nicholson's Gittes is in nearly every scene, so the audience learns only what he learns
  • The middle hour is dense with deeds, maps and names; inattention is punished

Where the gap is

Craft
10.09.3
Story
8.69.8
Direction
9.59.5
Performances
8.89.4

At a glance

FactBlade RunnerChinatown
Released25 June 198220 June 1974
DirectorRidley ScottRoman Polanski
StarringHarrison Ford, Edward James Olmos, Rutger HauerJack Nicholson, Faye Dunaway, John Huston
Runtime117 minutes130 minutes
StudioThe Ladd Company, Tandem ProductionsLong Road Productions, Paramount Pictures
GenreSci-Fi · Drama · NoirThriller · Noir · Crime

The two verdicts

Blade Runner

Blade Runner: the rain-soaked future noir that taught science fiction how to look

Blade Runner's slow pace, thin plotting and emotionally distant lead are real limitations, and they explain why it took audiences time to embrace it. Yet its vision of the future, its haunting score and Hauer's extraordinary performance make it a landmark of the medium. It scores 9.3, a hair below the very top only because its storytelling never quite matches the perfection of its world.

Read the full review →

Chinatown

Chinatown: a detective story where the crime is the city's plumbing

Chinatown earns its reputation through precision. Every scene carries information, every performance is pitched to the scale of the room, and the script's choice of subject, water rights in place of jewels or a dead partner, gives the genre a weight it rarely carries. It is held just short of the very top tier because its middle stretch asks a great deal of a modern viewer's patience, and because its density can leave a first-time audience a step behind rather than pleasurably so. Those are small costs. As a piece of storytelling about how power works in a modern city, very few films have matched it in the half-century since.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.