City of God · 2002
City of God: a crime epic that moves like a rumour and lands like a verdict
City of God review. Fernando Meirelles and Kátia Lund's 2002 Rio crime saga is fast, funny and appalling, and its young cast still carries every scene.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
City of God tells a story of children with guns at the speed of a pop song, and the shock is how long it takes to stop smiling. Fernando Meirelles and Kátia Lund open on a chicken escaping a barbecue, chased through narrow streets by a crowd of armed boys, and for the next two hours the film keeps that mixture of farce and terror in the same frame. It is a gangster saga, a coming-of-age story and an account of how a housing project built by the state became a place the state stopped entering.
- 9.3
- Editorial score
- #15
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2002
- Released
- 9.7
- Best at: Direction
What keeps it from being merely exciting is its point of view. Rocket, the narrator, is not a gangster and does not want to be one. He is the boy at the edge of every photograph, and the film is built from what he saw, what he heard second-hand and what he only understood later. That vantage makes the violence feel less like spectacle than like weather: something the whole neighbourhood lives under.
The premise
Cidade de Deus was a housing estate built in the 1960s on the western fringe of Rio de Janeiro, a place families were moved to rather than chose. The film begins there in that first decade, when the most feared criminals in the neighbourhood are the Tender Trio, three young men who hold up delivery lorries and share the takings with their neighbours. Rocket's older brother is one of them. A small boy called Li'l Dice trails after them, begging to be let in on a job, and the trio indulge him the way older boys do.
That first chapter is a period piece with the colour turned up: dust, sun, football on waste ground, a sense that crime is still something like mischief. Then a robbery at a motel goes badly, and the film quietly changes its mind about what kind of story it is telling. By the time it moves into the 1970s, the boys who were playing at being outlaws have learned that a gun is a business plan.
Bráulio Mantovani's adaptation keeps the novel's sprawl but gives it a spine. The script is divided into titled chapters, each one taking a character or a place, and it is happy to stop the main story to explain how an apartment changed hands or how a minor dealer got his nickname. Those detours are among the best things in it. They make the favela feel like a place with its own oral history, passed on by people who were there.

Direction
Meirelles came to the film from advertising, and the influence is obvious and, for once, an asset. He knows how to make an image read in half a second, and he uses that skill to keep a very large cast legible. Freeze frames introduce characters; a narrator's aside rewinds a scene so the viewer can see it again from another angle; split screens and whip pans hand the story from one corner of the estate to another without losing the thread.
What could have been a showreel is held together by a clear sense of time. The 1960s are shot warm and loose, the camera almost lazy. The 1970s grow tighter and busier. By the early 1980s the images are handheld, cold and crowded, and the editing has stopped allowing anyone to catch their breath. Daniel Rezende, whose editing won the BAFTA, makes that change in rhythm the film's real argument: the neighbourhood speeds up as the guns get bigger and the soldiers get younger.
Lund's contribution matters just as much, even if her credit is smaller on the poster. She had worked in Rio's favelas before the film, and the co-direction of the young cast, much of it built on workshops and improvisation rather than rehearsed text, is where the film gets its looseness. Scenes feel caught rather than staged. That quality is very hard to fake, and few crime films since have managed it.
How it plays
- Pace
- 9/10
- Rarely slows, and the final third barely stops for breath
- Violence
- 9/10
- Frequent, sudden and often committed by children
- Humour
- 7/10
- Plenty in the first hour, rarer as the decades pass
- Narrative density
- 8/10
- Dozens of named characters across three decades
- Accessibility
- 7/10
- Subtitled and harsh, but easy to follow
Performances
Most of the cast had never acted on film before, and many were recruited from Rio's favelas, including Cidade de Deus itself. The one established professional among the principals, Matheus Nachtergaele, plays the dealer Carrot. Everyone else had to be found and trained, and the result is a cast whose body language, slang and sense of threat are of a piece with the streets around them.
Leandro Firmino is the film's centre of gravity as the grown Li'l Dice, a performance of jittery, grinning menace; his moods turn without warning, and the room changes when he enters it. Douglas Silva, who plays the same character as a child, is if anything more frightening, because the giggle never quite leaves the face. Phellipe Haagensen gives Benny, the friendly dealer who fancies himself the neighbourhood's Robin Hood, an easy charm that makes the whole drug economy look briefly survivable.
Alexandre Rodrigues has the hardest job, because Rocket is mostly a witness. He makes passivity watchable, all sidelong looks and missed chances, and his voiceover has a dry, self-mocking tone that the film leans on in its darkest stretches. Seu Jorge, then better known as a musician, brings a weary dignity to a role that arrives later in the story, and Alice Braga, in her first film, makes a strong impression in a part that deserved more scenes.
If you run, the beast catches you; if you stay, the beast eats you.
Craft
César Charlone's cinematography is the image people remember: yellowed, overexposed daylight in the early scenes, a grainy, bruised palette later on. The look changes with the decades, so that the early years feel like faded snapshots, and it ties neatly to Rocket's ambition to become a photographer. The film keeps returning to the camera as an instrument of survival, the one tool in the favela that is not a gun.
The soundtrack does similar work. Antonio Pinto and Ed Côrtes provide a percussive, restless score, and the film is generous with Brazilian samba and funk of the period, which marks each era as clearly as the costumes and keeps the energy high in scenes that would otherwise be unbearable. Few crime films sound this alive; that is part of their seductive problem, and this one does not entirely solve it.
1997
Paulo Lins publishes the novel Cidade de Deus, drawn from his years in the estate
2002
Premieres out of competition at Cannes in May; opens in Brazil in August
2003
Released in the UK and the US in January; Daniel Rezende wins the BAFTA for editing
2004
Nominated for four Academy Awards, including Best Director and Best Adapted Screenplay
2024
HBO's miniseries City of God: The Fight Rages On returns to the estate two decades on
Where it sits
City of God is usually compared with Martin Scorsese's gangster films, and the comparison holds. It takes from Goodfellas the narrator who is half insider and half fan, the freeze frames, the joy in procedure and the sense that the good years were always borrowed. Its swagger with time, rewinding a scene to show what happened in the next room, is closer to Pulp Fiction. Where it differs from both is in the age of its gangsters and the absence of any world outside. Henry Hill could have been a cab driver. Nobody in Cidade de Deus is offered that choice.
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.69.8
- Story
- 9.19.4
- Direction
- 9.79.9
- Performances
- 9.49.7
Goodfellas edges it by 0.3. See them side by side
It also anticipates something. The film's success made room for Brazilian crime cinema and television abroad, and its makers went straight on to the series City of Men, set in the same world. Two decades later, a film like Roma shows how far Latin American cinema now travels; City of God was one of the films that first opened that road to a wide international audience.
For you if
- Anyone who loves the energy of Scorsese's crime films and wants to see that grammar used somewhere new
- Viewers interested in Brazil, in Rio, and in how cities produce their own violence
- Admirers of editing and cinematography that tell the story as much as the script does
Not for you if
- Anyone who finds violence against children impossible to watch, however briefly
- Viewers who want one central character and a tidy arc rather than a neighbourhood history
- Anyone wary of crime films that make their worst people look thrilling
For those who have already seen it, the obvious companion is the American film it learns most from, which reads differently after this one.
What works
- Rocket's narration turns a sprawling crime history into a story told over a beer
- Chapters that rewind and replay events make the favela's history easy to follow
- A non-professional young cast who never look as though they are acting
- Daniel Rezende's editing gives each decade its own speed and colour
What doesn’t
- The energy that makes it thrilling can make its violence look stylish
- Women are mostly girlfriends and victims, glimpsed at the edges of the plot
- The last third piles up so many names that minor players blur together
The verdict
City of God earns its reputation by doing two things that pull against each other: it makes the rise of a criminal economy exhilarating to watch, and it never lets the viewer forget who pays for it. The direction and editing are close to flawless, and the young cast gives the film a truth that no amount of professional polish could reproduce. The score stops short of the very top because the style occasionally runs ahead of the conscience, because its women are sidelined, and because the final stretch crowds out some of the characters it took time to build. Those are real reservations. They sit beside one of the most vivid, influential and humane crime films of its century, and one that has lost none of its speed.





