Skip to content

Head to head

City of God vs Goodfellas

Goodfellas takes it by 0.3, 9.6 against 9.3. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of City of God
City of God

2002 · Essential

  • Rocket's narration turns a sprawling crime history into a story told over a beer
  • Chapters that rewind and replay events make the favela's history easy to follow
  • The energy that makes it thrilling can make its violence look stylish
Cover of Goodfellas
Goodfellas

1990 · Masterpiece

  • Joe Pesci's Tommy is funny and terrifying in the same breath
  • The Copacabana tracking shot is a peerless piece of filmmaking
  • The relentless violence and cruelty can be hard to stomach

Where the gap is

Craft
9.69.8
Story
9.19.4
Direction
9.79.9
Performances
9.49.7

At a glance

FactCity of GodGoodfellas
Released18 May 200219 September 1990
DirectorFernando Meirelles, Kátia LundMartin Scorsese
StarringAlexandre Rodrigues, Leandro Firmino, Phellipe HaagensenJoe Pesci, Robert De Niro, Ray Liotta
Runtime130 minutes146 minutes
StudioO2 Filmes, VideoFilmesWarner Bros. Entertainment, Warner Bros. Pictures
GenreDrama · CrimeDrama · Crime · Biopic

The two verdicts

City of God

City of God: a crime epic that moves like a rumour and lands like a verdict

City of God earns its reputation by doing two things that pull against each other: it makes the rise of a criminal economy exhilarating to watch, and it never lets the viewer forget who pays for it. The direction and editing are close to flawless, and the young cast gives the film a truth that no amount of professional polish could reproduce. The score stops short of the very top because the style occasionally runs ahead of the conscience, because its women are sidelined, and because the final stretch crowds out some of the characters it took time to build. Those are real reservations. They sit beside one of the most vivid, influential and humane crime films of its century, and one that has lost none of its speed.

Read the full review →

Goodfellas

Goodfellas: Scorsese's electrifying, darkly funny anatomy of mob life

Goodfellas is one of the landmark films of American cinema, a crime story told with unmatched energy, wit and technical brilliance, and anchored by three indelible performances. Its unrelenting cruelty and a handful of thinly written supporting characters are the only small reservations. It earns a 9.6.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.