Downton Abbey · 2010
Downton Abbey: handsome, comforting period drama with a rose-tinted view of class
Our review of Downton Abbey, Julian Fellowes's ITV drama: gorgeous, warm and brilliantly cast, but increasingly melodramatic and soft on class.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Downton Abbey became a global phenomenon by offering something television had largely stopped providing: a sumptuous, unhurried, emotionally generous drama about a large English household, full of manners, scandal and beautiful clothes. Julian Fellowes's series revived the upstairs-downstairs tradition for a new generation and, for a time, was one of the most widely watched dramas in the world.
- 7.8
- Editorial score
- #72
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2010
- Released
- 6
- Seasons
Its appeal is easy to understand. It is warm, well acted and beautifully made. It is also a series that grows more melodramatic as it goes on, and whose affection for the aristocracy softens the harder questions its setting raises.
Michelle Dockery gives Lady Mary a cool, prickly strength, while Laura Carmichael turns her overlooked sister Edith into one of the most rewarding arcs of the series.
Story
The first series is the tightest. An inheritance crisis, triggered when the heirs to the estate die on the Titanic, sets up a plot about entailment, marriage and the arrival of a middle-class solicitor as the new heir. Below stairs, rivalries, romances and petty schemes play out in parallel, and Fellowes interweaves the two worlds with real dexterity. The second series moves into the First World War, and while its trench scenes are modest, its depiction of a house converted into a convalescent home is effective.
From the third series onwards, the drama relies increasingly on sudden tragedies, criminal accusations and romantic obstacles that repeat with small variations. Some storylines, including a much-criticised assault plot in the fourth series, are handled with less care than they demand. The final series gives many characters satisfying resolutions, but the journey there is uneven.

Characters and performances
The ensemble is the show's greatest asset. Maggie Smith's Violet, the Dowager Countess, steals nearly every scene with withering quips delivered with impeccable timing, and her sparring with Penelope Wilton's Isobel Crawley is a highlight throughout. Michelle Dockery gives Lady Mary a cool, prickly strength, while Laura Carmichael turns her overlooked sister Edith into one of the most rewarding arcs of the series. Downstairs, Jim Carter's Carson and Phyllis Logan's Mrs Hughes form a touching partnership, and Rob James-Collier's scheming footman Thomas becomes an unexpectedly sympathetic figure as his story develops.
Craft
Filmed largely at Highclere Castle, Downton looks magnificent. The costume design traces changing fashions across the years with precision, and John Lunn's sweeping theme became instantly recognisable. The direction is polished and traditional, favouring clarity and elegance over visual invention. Episodes move briskly, juggling many storylines without confusion.
Who it is for
Downton Abbey suits viewers who enjoy costume drama, ensemble storytelling and a gentle pace. It is family-friendly by the standards of modern prestige television. Those looking for a sharp social critique of the class system, or a strictly realistic portrait of domestic service, will find it too indulgent.
What works
- Maggie Smith's Dowager Countess delivers some of television's best one-liners
- Upstairs and downstairs storylines weave together with real skill
- Highclere Castle and the costume design are lavishly realised
- Charts the fading of the aristocratic order with warmth and nuance
What doesn’t
- Later series lean heavily on soap-opera contrivance and recycled crises
- Presents service in the great house with a notably rosy nostalgia
- Abrupt cast departures force some clumsy narrative turns
Head to head
- Craft
- 8.89.7
- Story
- 7.19.3
- Characters
- 8.18.8
- Performances
- 8.79.5
Chernobyl edges it by 1.6. See them side by side
The verdict
Downton Abbey earns a 7.8 for its terrific cast, handsome production and skilful weaving of upstairs and downstairs lives. Its later reliance on contrived crises, uneven handling of darker material and romanticised view of a deeply unequal world keep it well short of the top rank, but its comforts are real and its best moments endure.





