East of West · 2013
East of West is a stunning apocalyptic western that keeps its readers at arm's length
East of West sets Jonathan Hickman and Nick Dragotta's Death loose in a fractured alternate America, a bold, beautiful epic that can feel coldly schematic.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
East of West is one of the most striking-looking comics of the 2010s, and one of the most ambitious in its world-building. Jonathan Hickman builds a future America out of westerns, cyberpunk, Cold War paranoia and the Book of Revelation, and Nick Dragotta draws it with such confidence that even the strangest ideas feel solid.
- 7.8
- Editorial score
- #45
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2013
- Released
- 45
- Issues
For all that, it is easier to admire than to love. Hickman's instinct for systems, factions and prophecy produces a story that is often more diagram than drama, and the cast rarely escapes the roles the plan assigns them.
He is especially good at scale, staging vast landscapes and futuristic cities that still feel dusty and frontier-bound.
A continent at the end of days
The premise has rich mythic appeal. Death, a pale gunslinger in white, wanders a fractured America in which the Union, the Confederacy, the Endless Nation, the People's Republic and others coexist in a tense peace. Most of their rulers belong to a secret cabal bound by the Message, a text that promises the end of the world and their own salvation. The other three Horsemen, reborn and ruthless, want that ending to come on schedule. Death, having fallen in love with a mortal woman, has other plans, which puts him at war with both his siblings and the powers of the continent.
It is a big, operatic setup, and Hickman gives each nation a flavour and an ideology, from technocratic dynasties to spiritual warrior states.
Dragotta's design sense
Dragotta's art is the reason the book stands out. His line is lean and graphic, his action scenes are elegant, and his character designs are superb: Death's white hair and duster, the reborn Horsemen as unsettling children, and a gallery of rulers who look like tarot cards brought to life. He is especially good at scale, staging vast landscapes and futuristic cities that still feel dusty and frontier-bound.
Frank Martin's colours use restrained palettes, often dominated by a single hue per scene, which gives the book the look of a stylised film. Hickman's trademark design pages, with maps, sigils and text documents, add texture to the lore.
Prophecy over people
The difficulty lies in how the story is told. Hickman prefers portentous monologues and council scenes where leaders plot in riddles, and with dozens of important figures the narrative often jumps away from Death just as his thread gathers force. Many characters are defined by their allegiance and function rather than any inner life, which makes betrayals feel mechanical. Pacing suffers accordingly: some issues are gorgeous, largely static tableaux, while major events happen in brief bursts.
The series completed its planned story, which is to its credit, but the long gaps between some arcs and the sheer density of lore mean many readers will need to revisit earlier volumes to follow the endgame.
Who it is for
Fans of Hickman's architectural storytelling, from The Manhattan Projects to his Marvel event work, will be right at home. Readers who love Western mythology, strong design and slow-burn political fantasy should also give it a try. Those who need warm characters or a brisk plot may find it chilly going.
What works
- Nick Dragotta's clean, graphic art makes Death one of comics' coolest designs
- An audacious setting that mixes westerns, dystopia and biblical prophecy
- Hickman's power-politics plotting gives every nation a distinct agenda
- Frank Martin's bold, limited colour palettes are striking
What doesn’t
- A huge cast of scheming leaders leaves little room for emotional depth
- Long stretches of speeches and tableaux stall momentum
- Dense lore demands rereading and occasionally tips into opacity
Head to head
- Art
- 9.19.2
- Story
- 7.68.7
- Pacing
- 6.97.8
- Characters
- 7.09.3
Saga edges it by 1.0. See them side by side
The verdict
East of West is a visually superb, conceptually rich epic that deserves credit for its sheer audacity and for finishing its story. Its enormous cast, stately pacing and preference for pronouncements over people keep it from the top tier. A 7.8 reflects a good and often dazzling series whose emotional pull does not match its ambition.




