Fables · 2002
Fables is a brilliant fairy-tale war saga that outlives its own best story
Fables, Bill Willingham's saga of fairy-tale exiles in New York, peaks with its war against the Adversary and then struggles to find a reason to continue.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Fables begins with one of the best pitches of any modern comic. What if Snow White, the Big Bad Wolf, Prince Charming and the Three Little Pigs were refugees, living in a rundown corner of Manhattan, bickering over housing, taxes and old grudges while hiding from the empire that stole their homelands? Bill Willingham takes that idea and builds it, over roughly a decade, into a genuinely epic fantasy.
- 7.9
- Editorial score
- #43
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 2002
- Released
- 8.4
- Best at: Characters
Then the series keeps going. The consensus among readers is that Fables has a spectacular first half and a much less focused second one, and that consensus is broadly fair.
Pacing slackens, and threats that should feel apocalyptic lack the cumulative dread of the Adversary storyline.
Fabletown and the Adversary
The opening arc, Legends in Exile, is a crisp murder mystery that introduces Bigby as a chain-smoking detective and Snow White as the overworked deputy mayor actually keeping Fabletown afloat. It is followed by Animal Farm, a revolution among the non-human Fables that nods to Orwell, and from there Willingham widens the scope with patience. Prince Charming becomes a satirical politician, Boy Blue gets an unexpected hero's arc, and the mystery of the Adversary's identity is paid off with real flair.
The build towards open conflict with the Homelands is the book's peak, a mixture of espionage, military strategy and fairy-tale logic that makes the stakes feel both whimsical and deadly serious.

Buckingham's storybook pages
Lan Medina draws the first arc, but Mark Buckingham becomes the series' visual identity. His figures are clean and expressive, and his signature flourish is the decorated panel border: carved wood, ivy, Arabian tiles or icy filigree framing each page according to the setting. It gives the book the texture of an illustrated storybook without sacrificing clarity. James Jean's painted covers from the early run are among the most celebrated in modern comics.
Guest artists vary considerably in style, which keeps short interlude issues fresh but occasionally jars in the middle of an arc.
After the war
Once the central conflict is resolved, the series searches for a new engine. A new villain arrives, the focus scatters across Bigby and Snow's children and many side characters, and several arcs feel like extended epilogues. Pacing slackens, and threats that should feel apocalyptic lack the cumulative dread of the Adversary storyline. The ending, while respectable, arrives without the momentum the earlier issues promised.
There are also recurring criticisms worth noting. Some readers find the thinly veiled geopolitical allegory in parts of the Homelands storyline one-sided, and the treatment of certain female characters, from Cinderella's spy career to more troubling subplots, is inconsistent.
Who it is for
Fables is ideal for readers who love revisionist fairy tales, from Into the Woods to Once Upon a Time, and for anyone looking for a long, rich fantasy series to binge. It is also the basis for the Telltale game The Wolf Among Us. Readers can comfortably treat the story up to the end of the Adversary war as a complete saga and decide afterwards whether to continue.
What works
- A witty, endlessly fertile premise that reinvents public-domain characters
- Bigby Wolf and Snow White are a compelling, prickly central pairing
- The long build to open war with the Adversary is superbly plotted
- Mark Buckingham's ornate page borders give the book a storybook identity
What doesn’t
- Arcs after the Adversary conflict meander and repeat familiar beats
- Heavy-handed political allegory in places sits awkwardly with the fairy tale
- Several women are defined by romance or punishment more than agency
Head to head
- Art
- 8.39.2
- Story
- 7.88.7
- Pacing
- 7.07.8
- Characters
- 8.49.3
Saga edges it by 0.9. See them side by side
The verdict
At its best, Fables is inventive, funny and gripping, with a cast that makes centuries-old characters feel newly alive and a first half that deserves to be called a modern classic. Its sprawling, slower second half, uneven allegory and inconsistent handling of women weigh down the full run. A 7.9 reflects an excellent core story within a series that went on longer than its best ideas.




