Foundation · 2021
Foundation: gorgeous, ambitious Asimov that took a season to find its footing
Our review of Foundation, Apple TV+'s take on Isaac Asimov: epic visuals and a superb Lee Pace, weighed down by a meandering, overstuffed first season.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
Isaac Asimov's Foundation stories were long considered close to unfilmable. They span a thousand years, their heroes change every few chapters and their drama lies mostly in ideas, conversations and clever reversals rather than action. Apple's adaptation solves those problems by inventing freely, adding new characters, new conflicts and a striking political storyline at the heart of the Empire. The result is spectacular to look at and often intriguing, but it took time to become the series its ambitions promised.
- 7.0
- Editorial score
- #98
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2021
- Released
- 2
- Seasons
The first season was widely seen as handsome but confused. The second season marked a real improvement, and the show has since grown into one of the more distinctive large-scale science-fiction dramas on streaming.
The second season marked a real improvement, and the show has since grown into one of the more distinctive large-scale science-fiction dramas on streaming.
Story
The premise is compelling: a mathematician predicts that civilisation will fall and plans for what comes after. The early episodes, as Hari Seldon is tried for sedition and his followers are exiled to the edge of the galaxy, have a genuine sense of scale. Unfortunately, the first season then fragments. The Terminus storyline turns into a slow siege plot, Gaal Dornick's journey is weighed down by mystical elements and awkward twists, and the relationship between the two central women is asserted more than developed.
The Imperial storyline is the season's triumph. The idea that the Empire is ruled by successive clones of a single emperor, one young, one in his prime and one old, is not in Asimov's books, but it brilliantly dramatises his themes of stagnation and decline. The second season builds on this, adds a swashbuckling trader and a sharper sense of momentum, and knits its threads together more effectively.

Characters and performances
Lee Pace is the standout, playing Brother Day as a man of monumental arrogance slowly confronting the limits of his power. Terrence Mann and Cassian Bilton are excellent as the older and younger versions of the emperor, and Laura Birn gives Demerzel, the dynasty's ancient advisor, an eerie, sorrowful dignity. Jared Harris brings gravity to Seldon. Lou Llobell and Leah Harvey work hard, but their characters are often defined by plot mechanics, and the show's leaps across time make sustained investment difficult.
Craft
Foundation looks extraordinary. Its worlds, from the planet-wide city of Trantor to the icy wastes of Terminus, are conceived on a truly epic scale, and the costume and production design lend the Empire a cold, ritualistic grandeur. Bear McCreary's score is lush and memorable. The effects work is consistently high quality, and set pieces, including a disaster involving an orbital elevator early on, are staged with real impact.
Who it is for
Viewers who love large-scale science fiction and are willing to give a series time to develop will find a lot to enjoy, especially from the second season. Devotees of Asimov's novels should expect a loose reimagining rather than a faithful adaptation. Those who prefer tight, character-led storytelling may find the first season a struggle.
What works
- Lee Pace's imperious Brother Day is a commanding, layered creation
- The cloned-emperor storyline is a smart addition to Asimov's ideas
- World-building and effects are among the most lavish on television
- The second season is tighter, livelier and more confident
What doesn’t
- The first season meanders and buries its ideas under subplots
- Invented action and mysticism dilute the novels' intellectual appeal
- Leaps across centuries make some characters hard to invest in
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.09.0
- Story
- 6.69.2
- Characters
- 6.99.3
- Performances
- 7.89.4
Andor edges it by 2.2. See them side by side
The verdict
Foundation scores 7.0 across its first two seasons: its visual ambition, the inspired clone-emperor storyline and Lee Pace's performance deserve considerable credit, and the second season is clearly stronger. The meandering first season, uneven characterisation and additions that trade Asimov's intellect for spectacle keep it firmly in good-but-flawed territory.





