Frankenstein · 2025
Frankenstein: del Toro's lifelong project, ravishing to look at and in no hurry at all
Frankenstein review. Guillermo del Toro's Mary Shelley adaptation is a lavish Gothic melodrama, carried by Jacob Elordi's Creature and slowed by its own grandeur.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Guillermo del Toro has been talking about filming Frankenstein for most of his career, and the film he finally made feels like the work of somebody who has had decades to think about every candle, corridor and stitch. It is the most beautiful version of Mary Shelley's story yet put on screen, and also one of the most indulgent. Both of those facts come from the same place: a director so devoted to his material that he cannot bear to leave any of it out.
- 8.2
- Editorial score
- #75
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2025
- Released
- 9.4
- Best at: Craft
What he gets right matters more than what he overdoes. Most screen versions since 1931 have treated the Creature as the problem and the scientist as the tragic figure. Del Toro turns that round, as Shelley did, and makes the case that a father who abandons his child has done the monstrous thing. The film is a Gothic melodrama rather than a horror movie, and it is at its best when it stops trying to impress and lets Jacob Elordi's Creature look at the world for the first time.
The premise
The film opens in the Arctic, in 1857, aboard a Danish expedition ship frozen into the pack ice. The crew pull a gravely injured man off the ice, and before long something enormous comes after him across the snow. The man is Victor Frankenstein, and while the ship's captain waits to see whether his vessel will ever move again, Victor tells him how he came to be there.
His account begins in childhood, with a cold and exacting father and a mother he adored. It moves on to an Edinburgh lecture theatre where the adult Victor, now a surgeon with a gift for anatomy and none for diplomacy, demonstrates the reanimation of dead tissue to an audience that is horrified rather than impressed. A wealthy arms dealer, Henrich Harlander, sees something else in it, and offers money and an isolated tower in which to carry on the work. Victor accepts. The body he builds there, from parts taken from the dead, is the Creature.
That is as much as should be said in advance. The film is divided into two tales, the scientist's first and the Creature's second, and the second half reframes much of what the first presents. Del Toro's structure is Shelley's own, and it is the most faithful thing about his adaptation, more than any line of dialogue or plot point.
1818
Mary Shelley publishes Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus, anonymously
1931
James Whale's Universal film fixes the flat-headed, bolted image of the monster
2007
Del Toro calls a faithful Frankenstein the film he would most like to make
2023
After years in development at Universal, the project moves to Netflix
2025
World premiere in competition at Venice on 30 August; Netflix release on 7 November
2026
Nine Academy Award nominations, with wins for production design, costumes, and makeup and hairstyling

Direction
Del Toro's cinema has always loved monsters more than the people who hunt them, from the faun in Pan's Labyrinth to the amphibian man in The Shape of Water. This film makes that sympathy its whole argument, and the effect is cumulative. Each scene in Victor's half shows a man who confuses control with care, and each one makes the second half land harder. It is a director putting his thesis on the table and defending it for two and a half hours.
The weakness is pace. The first half returns to the same point, that Victor is vain, wounded and cruel, more often than it needs to, and several scenes exist mainly to show off a room. There is a version of this film twenty minutes shorter that loses nothing of substance. Del Toro also keeps his tone at a steady high pitch of operatic feeling, which is moving in the big moments and wearing in between them. Viewers who know his earlier work will recognise both the generosity and the excess.
What he never does is wink. There is no irony in this Frankenstein, no knowing nod to the Universal films or to the countless parodies since. He takes the story as seriously as Shelley did, and in a period full of franchise reboots that treat their source as a brand, that seriousness is its own kind of nerve.
Performances
Jacob Elordi is the film. His Creature is tall, pale and stitched like a quilt, but the performance is in the way he moves: hesitant, birdlike, discovering hands and light and sound as if each one were a gift. For a long stretch he has almost no words, and he does not need them. The design lets his face stay readable under the makeup, and del Toro's camera trusts that face completely. It is a performance of innocence, which is far harder to play than menace, and it earned Elordi an Academy Award nomination for Best Supporting Actor.
Oscar Isaac has the less grateful part and plays it without asking for sympathy. His Victor is charismatic in a lecture hall and unbearable in a laboratory, a man whose brilliance is real and whose capacity for love has been starved since childhood. Isaac lets the vanity show and the fear underneath it show more slowly, and it is the right choice for a story that needs the audience to change its mind about him.
The supporting cast is strong and uneven in what it is given. Christoph Waltz is a smooth and faintly reptilian patron, Charles Dance is chilling in a handful of scenes as Victor's father, and Felix Kammerer is warm as his younger brother William. Mia Goth, playing William's fiancée Elizabeth, has the hardest job: the script asks her to embody curiosity and compassion without giving her much of a life of her own, and she is often more symbol than person.
A father who abandons his child has done the monstrous thing; the film never lets Victor forget it.
Craft
This is where the film is beyond argument. The tower laboratory, with its circular window, its green glass cylinders and its vast Medusa relief, is the kind of set that used to be built only for silent epics, and it is matched by the frozen ship, the Edinburgh lecture theatre and a string of candlelit country houses. Dan Laustsen, del Toro's regular cinematographer, lights them in deep greens, ice blues and sudden blood reds, and very little of it feels like a screen with a background painted in later.
Costumes and makeup are equally precise. The Creature's design draws on Bernie Wrightson's celebrated illustrations of the novel rather than on the Universal monster, and the patchwork of his skin is detailed enough to tell its own story. Alexandre Desplat, scoring his third film for del Toro, writes for violin and strings in long, mournful lines, which suits a film more interested in loss than in shocks. The Academy gave the film three of its nine nominations as wins, all in design categories, and it is hard to imagine a more deserving set.
Where it sits
Against the long shelf of Frankenstein films, this one belongs with the minority that take Shelley's sympathies seriously. It shares the Arctic frame and the scale of ambition of Kenneth Branagh's 1994 version, and it is far more controlled than that film. It shares nothing with the bolted Universal icon except a name. Among del Toro's own work it sits closest to Crimson Peak in look and to The Shape of Water in heart, and it is both grander and more uneven than either.
Its closest relative in the catalogue is not another Gothic film at all. Blade Runner tells the same story in a different century: a made being, stronger than its makers and given no say in its own short life, who goes looking for the man responsible. One answers the question with rain and neon, the other with candles and ice.
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.410.0
- Story
- 7.68.6
- Direction
- 8.69.5
- Performances
- 8.58.8
Blade Runner edges it by 1.1. See them side by side
Anyone coming to the story fresh will get the most from the film by knowing nothing beyond the opening on the ice. Readers who know the novel will find the broad shape intact and a fair number of characters, motives and events changed, some for the better and some simply for spectacle.
For you if
- Anyone who reads Frankenstein as a story about parents and children rather than about science
- Admirers of del Toro's Gothic period films, and of production design for its own sake
- Viewers who want a long, sincere, unashamedly emotional costume drama
Not for you if
- Horror fans looking for dread and scares; there are few of either
- Anyone who wants a close, scene-by-scene adaptation of Shelley's novel
- Viewers with little patience for a slow first hour
For most readers the decision is less about whether to watch it than about where to start with del Toro if this is the first of his films they have heard of.
What works
- Jacob Elordi plays the Creature as a newborn, all curiosity before any menace
- The two-narrator structure restores the novel's argument that the maker is the monster
- Victor's tower laboratory is one of the great sets of recent cinema
- Alexandre Desplat's score is written for grief rather than for shocks
What doesn’t
- At 150 minutes, the first half spends too long on Victor's grievances
- Mia Goth's Elizabeth is more of an idea than a character
- Anyone wanting a horror film will find very few frights
The verdict
Frankenstein is the film Guillermo del Toro spent a career preparing to make, and it shows in every frame: the most lavishly designed version of Shelley's story there is, and the one that most clearly takes the Creature's side. Jacob Elordi gives it a heart that the screenplay alone could not, and the craft departments give it a world worth getting lost in. The score is held below the top tier by a first half that circles the same point too many times and a supporting cast that is sometimes decoration. Those are the costs of a director who loves his material too much to cut it, and most viewers who sit through the slow hour will find them worth paying.





