Skip to content

Head to head

Blade Runner vs Frankenstein

Blade Runner takes it by 1.1, 9.3 against 8.2. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Blade Runner
Blade Runner

1982 · Essential

  • Its dense, lived-in vision of Los Angeles remains unsurpassed
  • Rutger Hauer makes Roy Batty tragic, frightening and unforgettable
  • The plot is slow and thin by thriller standards
Cover of Frankenstein
Frankenstein

2025 · Excellent

  • Jacob Elordi plays the Creature as a newborn, all curiosity before any menace
  • The two-narrator structure restores the novel's argument that the maker is the monster
  • At 150 minutes, the first half spends too long on Victor's grievances

Where the gap is

Craft
10.09.4
Story
8.67.6
Direction
9.58.6
Performances
8.88.5

At a glance

FactBlade RunnerFrankenstein
Released25 June 198230 August 2025
DirectorRidley ScottGuillermo del Toro
StarringHarrison Ford, Edward James Olmos, Rutger HauerOscar Isaac, Jacob Elordi, Mia Goth
Runtime117 minutes150 minutes
StudioThe Ladd Company, Tandem ProductionsDouble Dare You, Demilo Films
GenreSci-Fi · Drama · NoirSci-Fi · Drama · Historical

The two verdicts

Blade Runner

Blade Runner: the rain-soaked future noir that taught science fiction how to look

Blade Runner's slow pace, thin plotting and emotionally distant lead are real limitations, and they explain why it took audiences time to embrace it. Yet its vision of the future, its haunting score and Hauer's extraordinary performance make it a landmark of the medium. It scores 9.3, a hair below the very top only because its storytelling never quite matches the perfection of its world.

Read the full review →

Frankenstein

Frankenstein: del Toro's lifelong project, ravishing to look at and in no hurry at all

*Frankenstein* is the film Guillermo del Toro spent a career preparing to make, and it shows in every frame: the most lavishly designed version of Shelley's story there is, and the one that most clearly takes the Creature's side. Jacob Elordi gives it a heart that the screenplay alone could not, and the craft departments give it a world worth getting lost in. The score is held below the top tier by a first half that circles the same point too many times and a supporting cast that is sometimes decoration. Those are the costs of a director who loves his material too much to cut it, and most viewers who sit through the slow hour will find them worth paying.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.