Game of Thrones · 2011
Game of Thrones: a towering fantasy epic that could not stick the landing
Our review of Game of Thrones, HBO's epic of power and dragons: a landmark of scale and ambition whose rushed final seasons damaged its legacy.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
For most of the 2010s, Game of Thrones was the closest thing television had to a shared global event. It proved that fantasy could be adult, political and brutal, it made a sprawling ensemble of unfamiliar actors into household names and it staged spectacle on a scale the medium had never attempted. Few series have been more influential.
- 8.5
- Editorial score
- #40
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2011
- Released
- 8
- Seasons
Few have also fallen so steeply in their audience's estimation. The final seasons, and especially the ending, provoked widespread disappointment that has coloured how the whole show is remembered. A fair assessment has to hold both truths.
Game of Thrones is essential viewing for anyone interested in fantasy or in the history of prestige television.
Story
The early seasons, closely following George R.R. Martin's novels, are remarkable. They take the familiar trappings of fantasy and apply the logic of real politics: honour is a liability, alliances are temporary and major characters are not protected by their importance to the plot. The effect is genuinely shocking, and the web of intrigue across multiple continents is handled with impressive clarity. Seasons three and four are often regarded as the show's peak.
Once the series moved beyond the published books, the writing changed. Plots accelerated, travel across vast distances became near instantaneous, and the careful cause and effect that had defined the early years gave way to spectacle and fan-pleasing moments. The seventh and eighth seasons, shorter than earlier ones, compress character arcs that needed room, and the resolution of several key storylines felt unearned to many viewers.

Characters and performances
The cast is outstanding. Peter Dinklage makes Tyrion Lannister witty, wounded and unpredictable. Lena Headey plays Cersei with icy, vulnerable menace, and Charles Dance's Tywin dominates every scene he appears in. Maisie Williams and Sophie Turner grew up on screen and gave Arya and Sansa some of the show's most rewarding transformations. Nikolaj Coster-Waldau's Jaime undergoes one of television's most intriguing arcs, while Emilia Clarke and Kit Harington carry major storylines with increasing assurance. Diana Rigg's late-career turn as Olenna Tyrell is a treat.
Craft
The production was vast. Filming across Northern Ireland, Croatia, Iceland, Spain and Morocco gave Westeros a tangible sense of place, and costumes, sets and creature effects improved season on season. Battle episodes directed by Neil Marshall and Miguel Sapochnik are landmarks of television action. Ramin Djawadi's music is essential to the show's identity. The later seasons' visual ambition remained high even as the writing faltered, although a notoriously dark night-time battle frustrated many viewers.
The show's frequent depictions of sexual violence, sometimes added or intensified relative to the books, drew sustained criticism and remain a significant blemish.
Who it is for
Game of Thrones is essential viewing for anyone interested in fantasy or in the history of prestige television. It is extremely violent and sexually explicit. Newcomers should go in knowing that the ending is contentious, and judge the journey on its own considerable merits.
What works
- Early seasons deliver political drama of rare cunning and consequence
- Peter Dinklage, Lena Headey and Charles Dance are superb
- Battle episodes set a new standard for television spectacle
- Ramin Djawadi's score and main theme are instantly iconic
What doesn’t
- The final two seasons rush character arcs to a divisive conclusion
- Sexual violence was often depicted in ways widely seen as gratuitous
- Once past the novels, dialogue and plotting grow noticeably thinner
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.38.7
- Story
- 8.06.8
- Characters
- 9.07.6
- Performances
- 9.18.6
Game of Thrones edges it by 1.3. See them side by side
The verdict
Game of Thrones scores 8.5 as a complete work. Its first half deserves a considerably higher mark for intricate, daring storytelling, extraordinary performances and unmatched scale. The hurried final seasons, a divisive conclusion and troubling treatment of sexual violence pull it down, leaving a flawed but monumental achievement.





