Getting Killed · 2025
Getting Killed: Geese sound like a band that has stopped asking permission
Getting Killed review. Geese's fourth album, made in ten days with Kenny Beats, turns jams, noise and crooning into the rock record of 2025.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
There is a moment, about a minute into "Trinidad", when it becomes clear that Geese have decided to stop being tasteful. The guitars stab in an odd metre, a horn section blurts in from nowhere, and Cameron Winter's voice lurches from a lazy drawl to something close to a scream. It is ugly, funny and completely in control, and it sets the terms for everything after it. Getting Killed is the sound of a young band discovering that the rough version is the good version.
- 8.8
- Editorial score
- #24
- Of 44 albums reviewed
- 2025
- Released
- 11
- Tracks
That discovery did not come out of nowhere. Geese had already made a nervy, Strokes-adjacent album for Partisan and a sprawling, theatrical follow-up, and Winter's quiet solo album at the end of 2024 had drawn more attention than either. The obvious move was to follow it with something polished. Instead the band went into a room with Kenny Beats, a producer best known for hip-hop, played for half an hour at a time, and kept the takes that wobbled. The result was one of the most praised rock albums of its year, and it earned that praise honestly.
Context
Geese formed in 2016 as teenagers at schools in Manhattan and Brooklyn, and their early reputation was as a precocious post-punk act, the kind of band that gets written about for its age. Projector was tight and nervy; 3D Country threw cowboy imagery, gospel backing singers and classic-rock swagger at the wall and kept most of what stuck. Both records showed a band with more ideas than discipline, which is not the worst problem to have.
Two things changed before this album. Guitarist Foster Hudson left at the end of 2023 to return to his studies, leaving the founding four. And Winter's solo record, Heavy Metal, a hushed piano-and-voice set released almost as an afterthought, found an audience far beyond the band's own. By the time Geese went west to record, there was an expectation that the group would follow its singer into quieter territory. Getting Killed is, in part, a refusal of that expectation.
2016
Geese form as high-school students in New York City
2021
Projector, their first album for Partisan Records and Play It Again Sam
2023
3D Country; guitarist Foster Hudson leaves at the end of the year
2024
Cameron Winter releases the solo album Heavy Metal in December
2025
Ten days of sessions in Los Angeles in January; Getting Killed follows on 26 September

The songs
The four singles map the album's range well. "Taxes", released first, is the closest thing here to a conventional rock anthem: a knotted, polyrhythmic opening that resolves into wide, ringing guitars and a chorus built to be shouted back, with lyrics that set biblical imagery against everyday dread. "Trinidad" is the opposite, a song that seems to be falling apart on purpose, held together only by its rhythm section and by Winter's sense of timing as he flips between deadpan and panic.
Between those poles sit the songs that make the album more than a collection of singles. "Cobra" is breezy and sunlit, nearly a pop song, its interlocking guitars recalling the softer end of the 1970s. "Husbands" rides a metronomic beat and a supple, slippery guitar line for four minutes without ever quite breaking into a sweat. "Au Pays du Cocaine" is a slow, swaying lullaby in which Winter sinks into his lowest register and sounds, for once, unguarded. It is the song most likely to convert the doubtful.
The title track is the record in miniature: a crunchy, upbeat opening that settles into a groove, blues licks traded across it and a sampled choir piled on top until it sounds like several songs arguing in a stairwell. "100 Horses" is the fastest and most militant thing here, a funk-rock stampede with Bassin playing as if the kit owes him money. "Bow Down" turns a staccato riff into a lopsided dance figure. The closer, Long Island City Here I Come, builds for more than six minutes while the vocal slowly dissolves into an anxious monologue, and it ends the album on a question rather than a bang.
| Track | Why |
|---|---|
| Taxes | The anthem; the clearest statement of what the band wants to sound like now |
| Au Pays du Cocaine | Winter at his most tender, and the melody that sticks longest |
| Trinidad | The deep end: odd metre, brass blasts, a singer pushing his voice to the edge |
| 100 Horses | Pure rhythm section, and the best case for playing it loud |
| Long Island City Here I Come | The closer that only makes full sense after the rest |
Production
Kenny Beats is an unusual choice for a rock band, and the reason for it is audible within seconds. The drums and bass are mixed as a hip-hop producer would mix them: dry, close and up front, with the guitars and keyboards arranged around them rather than on top. Bassin's playing, recorded hot and repeatedly reinforced, carries songs that would collapse in a more conventional mix. The effect is physical in a way that most guitar records of the decade are not.
The other half of the method is restraint about tidying. Takes where the tempo drifts or the voice cracks were kept rather than fixed. The band spent an entire session choosing a single handclap sample from a folder of thousands, which says something about where the care went. The detail is in the texture and the feel; the surfaces are left alone. Not every listener will hear that as a virtue. On the busier tracks the density can tip into murk, and the album's dynamics are mostly loud and louder, with only a handful of ballads to break them.
The rough take is not the demo here. It is the point.
Performance
This is a band record before it is a singer's record, and the playing is the best argument for it. Emily Green's guitar parts are sharp and economical, often doing the work of a hook while Winter is busy elsewhere. DiGesu locks into patterns and holds them for minutes, which is harder than it sounds and the reason the long grooves never go slack. Bassin, through all of it, is the album's most valuable player: inventive, aggressive and never showy for its own sake.
Winter himself is the obstacle and the prize. His voice is a strange, elastic instrument, drawling and nasal one moment, a cracked bellow the next, and he uses it theatrically, leaning into syllables and mangling vowels. To some ears that will sound like affectation, and the lyrics, which favour surreal non sequiturs and dark jokes over narrative, do not always help. Heard alongside the band rather than in front of it, though, the mannerisms make sense: he is playing the voice as another rhythm part, and when it lands, as it does on "Au Pays du Cocaine" and "Taxes", it is thrilling.
How it sounds
- Energy
- 8/10
- Mostly loud and driving, with two or three deliberate lulls
- Intimacy
- 5/10
- The ballads are close; the rest is a room full of noise
- Density
- 8/10
- Layers of brass, samples and guitars, sometimes too many
- Accessibility
- 6/10
- Two or three songs for anyone; the rest takes a few plays
Sequencing and cohesion
At about three-quarters of an hour and eleven songs, Getting Killed is the right length, and its bookends are well chosen: the noisy invitation of "Trinidad" at the front, the slow dissolve of the closer at the back. The problem is in the middle, where "Getting Killed" and "Islands of Men", nearly eleven minutes of groove between them, sit side by side. Each works on its own; together they flatten the momentum the first three songs built. "100 Horses" restores it, and the run from there to the end is the strongest stretch on the record.
What holds the album together is not a sound so much as an attitude. Ballads and noise pieces share the same rhythm section and the same refusal to smooth things over, so even the gentlest songs feel like they belong to the same night. That coherence is what separates this from 3D Country, which had better individual moments in places and a much weaker sense of itself.
Legacy
It is early to talk about legacy for a record barely a year old, but Getting Killed already looks like the album that moved Geese from promising to central. It topped several year-end lists and was widely described as the rock record of 2025, and it did that without a concession to radio or to the quieter success of Winter's solo work. The comparison it invites is to a band changing shape in public, as Radiohead did between OK Computer and *Kid A*, even if the sound could hardly be more different.
What it leaves behind is a template other young bands will copy: record together, keep the mistakes, put the drums first. Whether Geese can repeat the trick is a question for the next record. For now this one stands on its own.
For you if
- Anyone who wants a rock band to sound dangerous again, mess and all
- Listeners who came for Cameron Winter's solo record and are curious about the band
- Fans of rhythm-heavy art rock, from Talking Heads to the noisier end of post-punk
Not for you if
- Anyone who finds a theatrical, mannered vocal style hard work
- Listeners who want lyrics that tell a story rather than throw images
- Those who prefer polished, carefully layered production
For readers who want the lineage rather than the latest thing, the catalogue has a clear next step.
What works
- A rhythm section recorded loud and forward, so the grooves carry the songs
- Cameron Winter's voice moves from croon to shriek inside a single verse
- "Taxes" and "Au Pays du Cocaine" give the chaos two melodies anyone can hum
- Rough edges left in on purpose make the record feel played, not assembled
What doesn’t
- The middle stretch sags when two long grooves sit back to back
- Lyrics lean on non sequitur, and some lines read as noise rather than meaning
- Winter's mannered delivery will put off listeners before the band wins them over
Head to head
- Cohesion
- 8.49.5
- Production
- 8.69.9
- Performance
- 9.39.4
- Songwriting
- 8.99.5
Pet Sounds edges it by 0.8. See them side by side
The verdict
Getting Killed is the record on which Geese stop sounding like a clever band with influences and start sounding like themselves. The decision to cut it fast, play it loud and leave the seams showing gives it an urgency that most rock albums of its year lacked, and a rhythm section this good earns the space it is given. The score stops short of essential because the middle stretch drifts, the lyrics too often settle for strangeness over meaning, and Winter's delivery is a toll some listeners will not want to pay. Those reservations are real. They are also the cost of an album that takes risks a more careful band would have avoided, and almost every one of those risks pays off.





