Skip to content
Album reviewMasterpiece#1 in albums

Loveless · 1991

Loveless: the guitar record that made the guitar sound like weather

Loveless review. My Bloody Valentine's 1991 album bends guitars, voices and samples into one warm blur, and three decades on nothing else sounds quite like it.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet9 min read

Masterpiece

Editorial score out of 10

Louder, faster and dirtier is how rock usually reinvents the guitar. Loveless did it by making the guitar stop behaving like a guitar. Kevin Shields bends the pitch of every chord as he strums it, stacks the result until it becomes a single shimmering surface, and then lays two voices just under that surface, close enough to hear and too far away to follow. The effect is less a wall of sound than a climate.

9.6
Editorial score
#1
Of 44 albums reviewed
1991
Released
11
Tracks

That sounds like a description of something difficult, and the reputation does not help: two and a half years in the studio, a label said to have nearly broken itself paying for it, a band that took twenty-two years to make the next one. The surprise is how inviting it is. Underneath the noise there are pop songs with hooks you can hum, and a warmth that most noisy records never reach. We think it is the most influential guitar album of its decade, and still one of the most pleasurable.

Underneath the noise there are pop songs with hooks you can hum, and a warmth that most noisy records never reach.

Context

My Bloody Valentine had spent most of the 1980s as a scrappy indie band before their first album, Isn't Anything, gave them a sound of their own in 1988. Loveless was meant to follow quickly. Instead, sessions that began at Blackwing Studios in February 1989 drifted through a long list of London rooms, with Shields discarding engineers who wanted to do things the conventional way and keeping only a few, Alan Moulder and Anjali Dutt among them, whom he trusted. Two EPs, Glider and Tremolo, kept the band in the shops while the album took shape, and each carried a song that ended up on it.

The cost of the record became a story of its own, inflated in the press and disputed by Shields ever since. What is not in dispute is that Creation's founder, Alan McGee, let the band go soon after it came out, and that Loveless reached only number 24 on the UK albums chart. Its standing grew afterwards, as the band struggled to follow it and a generation of musicians took it apart to learn how it was done. Read now, the delays look less like indulgence than like a person refusing to release something that sounded almost right.

  1. 1988

    Isn't Anything, the band's first album, comes out on Creation

  2. 1989

    Sessions for the second album begin at Blackwing Studios in London

  3. 1990

    The Glider EP is released, with "Soon" as its lead track

  4. 1991

    The Tremolo EP introduces "To Here Knows When"; Loveless follows in November

  5. 2012

    A remastered edition, overseen by Shields, is released

  6. 2013

    m b v, the follow-up, finally arrives twenty-two years later

Loveless
LovelessMy Bloody Valentine, from the official "To Here Knows When" video

The songs

Strip the production away and the songs are short, plainly built and catchy. "Only Shallow" opens the album with a snare hit and a guitar line that swoops like a siren, then drops into a verse Bilinda Butcher sings almost under her breath. "When You Sleep" is the closest thing to a conventional single: a melody that sounds like a duet but is Shields alone, a dozen or so takes of his voice played together, over a riff that keeps sliding off pitch and back again. "Blown a Wish" is the prettiest thing here, Butcher's voice doubled into a kind of choir over guitars that glow rather than roar.

The longer pieces are where the record earns its reputation. "To Here Knows When" barely has a rhythm at all: a single smeared chord, a faint pulse, a vocal that sounds as if it is coming from the next room. "Sometimes" is a slow, swaying ballad in which the distortion hums like an organ under a melody that never raises its voice. "Soon", which closes the album, sets that same guitar language over a loping groove borrowed from dance music, and turns the whole thing into something you could move to.

Where to start
TrackWhy
"Only Shallow"The opening statement: the glide guitar at its loudest and most melodic
"When You Sleep"The most direct pop song on the album, and the easiest way in
"To Here Knows When"The record at its most abstract; the one that divides people
"Sometimes"A ballad hidden inside the noise, and the slowest track here
"Soon"A dance groove under the guitars, and the ending everything builds towards
Watch
Loveless — trailer

Production

The technique that defines Loveless is simple to describe. Shields holds the tremolo arm of his guitar while he strums, so every chord wavers in pitch as it sounds, then layers takes of that playing until the wobble becomes the texture. Much of the album was recorded in mono, with the guitar placed squarely in the centre rather than spread across the speakers, which is why the sound feels like a single mass instead of a band in a room. Samples of feedback and guitar, played back from a keyboard, fill in the gaps.

The vocals are the other half of the trick. Shields and Butcher sing quietly, often in unison, and the mix places them inside the guitars rather than on top of them, so a line arrives as a shape before it arrives as words. That choice is the source of the album's dreamlike quality and of its main frustration. Shields and Butcher worked hard on the words, then made sure they could barely be heard; the band have long declined to say what several of them are. Anyone who wants a singer to tell them something will find the record withholding by design.

How it sounds

Volume
8/10
Loud, but rounded rather than harsh
Intimacy
7/10
Voices close and hushed, though always half-hidden
Density
10/10
Every frequency filled, every gap closed
Accessibility
5/10
Inviting once it clicks; baffling before
Gallery · 3 imagesMy Bloody Valentine, from the official "Only Shallow" video · My Bloody Valentine, from the official "Soon" video · My Bloody Valentine, from the official "To Here Knows When" video

Performance

For a band album, Loveless is unusually close to a solo record. Shields wrote nearly all the music and has said that he is the only musician on the songs apart from "Touched", the short, eerie interlude that drummer Colm Ó Cíosóig composed and programmed on his own. Bassist Debbie Googe is credited but did not play, and Butcher's role is above all as a voice and a co-writer of about a third of the lyrics. Even most of the drums are built from samples of Ó Cíosóig's playing, recorded while he was unwell and looped with a precision a live take would struggle to match; he plays live on only a few tracks, "Only Shallow" among them.

None of that makes the record feel cold. Shields' playing is physical, a matter of hands and springs and amplifiers pushed to their edge, and the slight imperfections of the pitch-bending are what make the guitars sound alive. Butcher's voice, in particular, carries more than its volume suggests. On "Loomer" and "Blown a Wish" she gives the noise a centre of gravity, and the album is at its warmest whenever she leads.

Sequencing and cohesion

Loveless works best as one continuous listen. The tracks share a palette so tightly that, on a first pass, the middle of the album, from "I Only Said" through "Come in Alone", can blur into a single long drift. That is the record's most common complaint, and it is a fair one. Given a few plays, though, each track separates out: "I Only Said" for its strange, wah-like guitar line made with an equaliser rather than a pedal, "Come in Alone" for its stop-start lurch, "What You Want" for its brightness.

The running order is careful in ways that only become clear with time. "Only Shallow" announces the method at full force, "Touched" acts as a palate cleanser before the album's most abstract stretch, and "Soon" waits until the end to show that all this noise can also make you dance. It lasts under fifty minutes, and it feels shorter.

Legacy

It is hard to name an album that has been more studied by guitarists, producers and bands who never sounded anything like it. Whole scenes, from the dream-pop and shoegaze revivals to electronic producers who borrowed its blur, trace a line back to these eleven tracks. Set it beside another landmark from the autumn of 1991 and the difference is striking: one record made the guitar louder and plainer, the other made it vaguer and stranger, and both reset what a rock band could be.

Head to head

Cohesion
9.78.8
Production
10.08.6
Performance
9.49.3
Songwriting
9.09.2

Loveless edges it by 0.6. See them side by side

The comparison is unfair to neither. Nevermind is the record for anyone who wants the song in front, Loveless the one for anyone who wants to disappear into the sound. A decade later Radiohead's Kid A would take a similar turn away from the guitar as lead voice, and the two make a revealing pair; see our entry for Kid A.

For you if

  • Listeners who hear production as part of the songwriting, not packaging around it
  • Anyone who loves dream pop, ambient music or guitar noise and wants to hear where much of it came from
  • People who like an album to be played whole, loud and in order

Not for you if

  • Anyone who listens for lyrics and wants to know what the singer is saying
  • Listeners who find sustained noise tiring rather than enveloping, even at low volume

For a first listen, the album's own opening track is the right door, and the band's official site lists the current editions and where they can be heard.

What works

  • Guitars that bend in pitch as they ring, so chords seem to melt and re-form
  • Vocals mixed as texture, which turns simple melodies into something half-remembered
  • "Soon" closes on a dance groove that few guitar bands of 1991 would have tried
  • Eleven tracks that share one palette yet never repeat the same trick

What doesn’t

  • Lyrics are close to unintelligible, so anyone who listens for words gets little
  • The mid-album run blurs together on a casual first play
  • The sound depends on volume and a decent system; laptop speakers flatten it
MasterpieceHow we score

The verdict

Loveless earns its place near the top of the scale because it did something new with the most familiar instrument in popular music, and because it did it without sacrificing pleasure. The pitch-bent guitars, the mono mass of sound and the voices folded inside it add up to a world rather than a style, and three decades of imitators have not reproduced it. The songwriting is simpler than the reputation suggests, and the deliberately obscured lyrics will always keep some listeners outside. Those are real limits, but they are the cost of the album's whole idea. Heard loud and in order, it remains one of the most complete and influential records of its era.

Quick answers

Is Loveless worth listening to?

Voxizer scores Loveless (1991) 9.6 out of 10 — masterpiece. Loveless earns its place near the top of the scale because it did something new with the most familiar instrument in popular music, and because it did it without sacrificing pleasure. The pitch-bent guitars, the mono mass of sound and the voices folded inside it add up to a world rather than a style, and three decades of imitators have not reproduced it.

Who will enjoy Loveless?

Listeners who hear production as part of the songwriting, not packaging around it. Anyone who loves dream pop, ambient music or guitar noise and wants to hear where much of it came from. People who like an album to be played whole, loud and in order.

Who should skip Loveless?

Anyone who listens for lyrics and wants to know what the singer is saying. Listeners who find sustained noise tiring rather than enveloping, even at low volume.

What is Loveless like, in short?

A guitar album that sounds like nothing before it, and very little since has caught up. Behind the haze sit short, hummable pop songs; the noise is a texture, not a barrier. Production is the instrument: the mix, the samples and the pitch-bending are the point. The vocals are mostly unintelligible by design, which some listeners never forgive.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Loveless yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for albums: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.