Nevermind · 1991
Nevermind: Nirvana wrap punk fury in pop hooks and change rock's direction
Nevermind is Nirvana's 1991 breakthrough, a ferocious, melodic grunge album that brought underground rock to the mainstream and still sounds urgent today.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Few albums have altered the direction of popular music as abruptly as Nevermind. Nirvana were an underground band from the Pacific Northwest whose debut had been a sludgy, low-budget affair. Their second album, made with a major label and a much bigger production budget, took the energy of punk and hardcore and married it to melodies as instantly memorable as those of The Beatles. Within months, it had displaced pop superstars at the top of the charts and turned alternative rock into the sound of a generation.
- 9.0
- Editorial score
- #21
- Of 44 albums reviewed
- 1991
- Released
- 12
- Tracks
What matters most, more than three decades later, is that the songs still hold up. The context explains its impact, but the writing and playing explain its endurance.
Yet that clarity also helped the songs reach millions of listeners who might never have heard underground rock.
The songs
Smells Like Teen Spirit opens the album with one of the most recognisable guitar riffs in rock, its quiet verses and explosive choruses becoming a template copied endlessly. In Bloom follows with a sing-along chorus that mocks the very people who would sing along to it. Come as You Are is a slinky, watery mid-tempo track, and Lithium swings between resigned calm and cathartic screaming.
Polly, sung over an acoustic guitar, is a disturbing song told from the perspective of an abuser, a stark contrast to the noise around it. Drain You, perhaps the most underrated track, bursts with melody and energy. The album closes with Something in the Way, a hushed, cello-backed song that suggests a very different path the band could have taken.

Sound and performance
Butch Vig's production captured the band with clarity and power, and Andy Wallace's mix pushed it further, giving the guitars a thick, radio-friendly sheen. Cobain himself later expressed ambivalence about how polished it sounded, and fans of the band's rawer work still debate whether the gloss diluted them. Yet that clarity also helped the songs reach millions of listeners who might never have heard underground rock.
Dave Grohl's drumming is a revelation, driving the songs with enormous force and surprising finesse. Krist Novoselic's bass lines anchor the melodies, and Cobain's voice, moving from a mumble to a raw howl, gives even the simplest lyrics a sense of desperation.
Uneven moments
The second half of the album is not as consistently strong as the first. Territorial Pissings is a short, frantic punk outburst that works better as an energy release than a song, and Stay Away and On a Plain, while enjoyable, are less distinctive than the singles. Lounge Act is a fine song that has been somewhat overshadowed.
Who it is for
Nevermind remains the natural entry point for anyone interested in alternative rock, grunge or the history of 1990s music. Listeners who want a rawer experience can follow it with In Utero or the band's acoustic MTV Unplugged performance.
What works
- Kurt Cobain's gift for melody hides inside the noise on nearly every song
- Dave Grohl's drumming is thunderous, precise and hugely influential
- Smells Like Teen Spirit, In Bloom and Lithium form a remarkable run
- Quiet-loud dynamics are used with real emotional purpose
What doesn’t
- The polished mix softened the band's rawer live sound
- The second half is less consistent than the famous opening stretch
- Territorial Pissings and Stay Away feel more like blasts of energy than songs
Head to head
- Cohesion
- 8.89.6
- Production
- 8.69.5
- Performance
- 9.39.4
- Songwriting
- 9.29.6
OK Computer edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Nevermind scores 9.0: an exceptional album whose songwriting and performances made it one of the most influential rock records ever released. Its opening run of songs is close to perfect. A slightly uneven second half and a polished sound that sometimes blunts the band's edges keep it from the very top tier, but its power remains undeniable.




