In Rainbows · 2007
In Rainbows: Radiohead's warmest, most human record hides behind a famous stunt
In Rainbows is Radiohead's 2007 album, first sold as a pay-what-you-want download: a warm, tender record of rhythm and longing that outlived its release model.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
The story of In Rainbows is usually told as a business story. Radiohead, free of their record contract, released the album online and let fans decide what to pay, a move that dominated headlines and triggered years of debate about the future of the music industry. That episode is important, but it can obscure the more lasting truth: this is the most intimate and physically beautiful album the band has made.
- 9.1
- Editorial score
- #19
- Of 44 albums reviewed
- 2007
- Released
- 10
- Tracks
After records defined by alienation and anxiety, In Rainbows feels like a band reconnecting with warmth, rhythm and the human body. It remains a favourite among fans for exactly that reason.
In Rainbows is arguably the best entry point into Radiohead for listeners who find OK Computer too grand or Kid A too cold.
The songs
15 Step opens with a skittering electronic beat in an unusual time signature before Jonny Greenwood's guitar and a burst of children's voices bring it to life. Nude, a song the band had been working on for about a decade, finally arrives as a hushed, slow-motion ballad, Thom Yorke's falsetto floating over a lithe bass line from Colin Greenwood. Weird Fishes/Arpeggi is the album's emotional core, interlocking guitar patterns building steadily until the song seems to fall into deep water.
Reckoner is perhaps the most gorgeous thing Radiohead have recorded, a shimmering track of tambourine, falsetto and strings. House of Cards is an unusually sensual song for this band, and Jigsaw Falling into Place tightens into a nervy, propulsive account of a night out.

How it sounds
Nigel Godrich's production strikes a balance between organic and electronic that the band had been searching for since the early 2000s. Guitars ring with warmth, Jonny Greenwood's string arrangements add richness without drama, and Phil Selway's drumming is crisp and fluid throughout. The mix is spacious and detailed, and the arrangements reveal new layers over repeated plays.
Not everything fits seamlessly. Bodysnatchers is a thrilling, distorted rocker, but it disrupts the gentle mood of the opening sequence. Faust Arp is lovely but slight, and Videotape, a spare piano piece built around a stuttering rhythm, closes the album so quietly that it can feel unresolved until it clicks.
Themes
The lyrics are less concerned with technology and politics than on earlier records, and more with bodies, relationships and endings. There is a sense of mortality running through the album, but it is expressed with tenderness rather than dread. Yorke's delivery is correspondingly softer, and the band sounds more relaxed than at any point since their early days.
Who it is for
In Rainbows is arguably the best entry point into Radiohead for listeners who find OK Computer too grand or Kid A too cold. It suits late evenings and headphones, and its songs work both as a continuous listen and on their own.
What works
- The band's most sensual, emotionally direct writing
- Weird Fishes/Arpeggi and Reckoner are among their finest songs
- Phil Selway's drumming gives the whole album a supple, living pulse
- A tight ten-track sequence with no wasted minutes
What doesn’t
- Less thematically ambitious than OK Computer or Kid A
- Bodysnatchers' fuzz-rock thrash sits a little oddly in the flow
- The spare closing Videotape can feel anticlimactic on early listens
Head to head
- Cohesion
- 9.19.5
- Production
- 9.39.6
- Performance
- 9.29.1
- Songwriting
- 9.29.0
Kid A edges it by 0.2. See them side by side
The verdict
In Rainbows scores 9.1: exceptional, and the most emotionally generous album in Radiohead's catalogue. Its songwriting, production and performances are consistently superb, and its release model was a genuine landmark in music distribution. It lacks the paradigm-shifting ambition of the band's two most celebrated records, and one or two tracks feel slightly out of step, but as a collection of songs it may be their finest.





