Skip to content

Head to head

In Rainbows vs Kid A

Kid A takes it by 0.2, 9.3 against 9.1. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of In Rainbows
In Rainbows

2007 · Essential

  • The band's most sensual, emotionally direct writing
  • Weird Fishes/Arpeggi and Reckoner are among their finest songs
  • Less thematically ambitious than OK Computer or Kid A
Cover of Kid A
Kid A

2000 · Essential

  • A total reinvention that avoids every obvious move after OK Computer
  • Everything in Its Right Place is one of the great album openers
  • Treefingers' ambient drift halts momentum for some listeners

Where the gap is

Cohesion
9.19.5
Production
9.39.6
Performance
9.29.1
Songwriting
9.29.0

At a glance

FactIn RainbowsKid A
Released10 October 20072 October 2000
ArtistRadioheadRadiohead
LabelXL RecordingsParlophone, Capitol Records
Tracks1010
Length42:3949:57
GenreAlternative rock · ElectronicAlternative rock · Art rock · Electronic

The two verdicts

In Rainbows

In Rainbows: Radiohead's warmest, most human record hides behind a famous stunt

In Rainbows scores 9.1: exceptional, and the most emotionally generous album in Radiohead's catalogue. Its songwriting, production and performances are consistently superb, and its release model was a genuine landmark in music distribution. It lacks the paradigm-shifting ambition of the band's two most celebrated records, and one or two tracks feel slightly out of step, but as a collection of songs it may be their finest.

Read the full review →

Kid A

Kid A: Radiohead dismantle rock music and build something eerie and lasting

Kid A scores 9.3. Its production, cohesion and sheer audacity make it one of the most significant albums of its time, and its reputation has only grown. It stops short of the landmark tier because some of its individual songs are less compelling than the whole, and its emotional distance can make it more admired than loved. Few records have taken such a risk and been so thoroughly vindicated.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.