Skip to content

Head to head

Loveless vs Nevermind

Loveless takes it by 0.6, 9.6 against 9.0. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of Loveless
Loveless

1991 · Masterpiece

  • Guitars that bend in pitch as they ring, so chords seem to melt and re-form
  • Vocals mixed as texture, which turns simple melodies into something half-remembered
  • Lyrics are close to unintelligible, so anyone who listens for words gets little
Cover of Nevermind
Nevermind

1991 · Essential

  • Kurt Cobain's gift for melody hides inside the noise on nearly every song
  • Dave Grohl's drumming is thunderous, precise and hugely influential
  • The polished mix softened the band's rawer live sound

Where the gap is

Cohesion
9.78.8
Production
10.08.6
Performance
9.49.3
Songwriting
9.09.2

At a glance

FactLovelessNevermind
Released4 November 199124 September 1991
ArtistMy Bloody ValentineNirvana
LabelCreation Records, Sire RecordsGeffen Records
Tracks1112
Length48:3142:38
GenreRock · Shoegaze · Dream popAlternative rock · Grunge

The two verdicts

Loveless

Loveless: the guitar record that made the guitar sound like weather

Loveless earns its place near the top of the scale because it did something new with the most familiar instrument in popular music, and because it did it without sacrificing pleasure. The pitch-bent guitars, the mono mass of sound and the voices folded inside it add up to a world rather than a style, and three decades of imitators have not reproduced it. The songwriting is simpler than the reputation suggests, and the deliberately obscured lyrics will always keep some listeners outside. Those are real limits, but they are the cost of the album's whole idea. Heard loud and in order, it remains one of the most complete and influential records of its era.

Read the full review →

Nevermind

Nevermind: Nirvana wrap punk fury in pop hooks and change rock's direction

Nevermind scores 9.0: an exceptional album whose songwriting and performances made it one of the most influential rock records ever released. Its opening run of songs is close to perfect. A slightly uneven second half and a polished sound that sometimes blunts the band's edges keep it from the very top tier, but its power remains undeniable.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.