Hellboy · 1994
Hellboy marries pulp, folklore and Mignola's shadows into something utterly singular
Hellboy, Mike Mignola's folklore-steeped Dark Horse saga, pairs iconic chiaroscuro art with dry humour and myth, though its structure can be hard to navigate.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Few comics have a visual identity as instantly recognisable as Hellboy. Mike Mignola's heavy blacks, geometric shapes and silent, brooding panels created a style that countless artists have borrowed and nobody has quite replicated. What makes the series last, though, is how Mignola marries that look to a sensibility steeped in folk tales, pulp adventure and the weird fiction of H.P. Lovecraft.
- 8.9
- Editorial score
- #22
- Of 53 comics reviewed
- 1994
- Released
- 50
- Issues
The result is part monster-punching romp, part ghost-story anthology and part slow-burning apocalypse. It is sometimes awkward to navigate, but at its best it is unlike anything else in the medium.
Mignola draws with enormous economy, using shadow to suggest rather than show, and often cuts away to still-life panels of statues, candles or skulls to set a mood.
A demon with a day job
The first miniseries, Seed of Destruction, sets up the essentials: Hellboy's origins, the Bureau, fish-man Abe Sapien, pyrokinetic Liz Sherman and the scheming Grigori Rasputin, whose plans for Hellboy's destiny will echo across the series. Mignola co-plotted it with John Byrne providing the script, and it plays as a solid, fairly traditional superhero-horror launch.
The series truly finds its voice in the shorter stories that follow. Tales such as The Corpse, drawn from Irish folklore, and The Wolves of Saint August show Mignola's gift for compression: a village, a curse, a monster and a laconic hero who would rather be anywhere else. Hellboy himself is wonderfully understated, a big, grumbling investigator with a soft spot for the underdog and no patience for prophecy.

The Mignola look
The art is the centrepiece. Mignola draws with enormous economy, using shadow to suggest rather than show, and often cuts away to still-life panels of statues, candles or skulls to set a mood. His storytelling has a rhythm closer to cinema than to conventional superhero comics, with long silences broken by abrupt violence. Dave Stewart's colours, which became integral to the series, use earthy tones and startling flashes of red to make each page feel like an old woodcut brought to life.
As the saga expanded, Mignola handed the art on some major arcs to Duncan Fegredo and to the legendary Richard Corben, whose grotesque, earthy style suited the Appalachian and British folk material. Both are strong, though Mignola's own pages remain the ideal.
Finding a way in
The biggest barrier is structure. Hellboy was never a conventional ongoing series but a patchwork of miniseries, short stories and one-shots, with a sprawling spin-off universe around it, including B.P.R.D. Newcomers can struggle to know what to read next, and the long-form mythology, particularly the apocalyptic threads, is sometimes delivered through cryptic exposition and visions rather than drama. The supporting characters, beyond a handful, rarely get the interiority that Hellboy himself enjoys.
Who it is for
Hellboy suits readers who love folk horror, Lovecraftian fiction and adventure pulp, and anyone who has enjoyed Guillermo del Toro's film adaptations and wants the stranger, quieter source. The omnibus and library editions, which collect the stories in order, make it far easier to follow than it once was.
What works
- Mignola's slabs of black and bold shapes form one of comics' most iconic styles
- Short folklore tales are atmospheric, eerie and often quietly moving
- Hellboy's weary, working-class humour grounds the cosmic stakes
- Dave Stewart's colours perfectly complement the stark, graphic art
What doesn’t
- The fragmented publishing history makes reading order confusing
- Seed of Destruction is a fairly conventional opening compared with what follows
- Character depth is sparse; supporting cast can feel like sketches
Head to head
- Art
- 9.69.8
- Story
- 8.59.2
- Pacing
- 8.27.6
- Characters
- 8.69.4
Berserk edges it by 0.3. See them side by side
The verdict
Hellboy is a landmark of creator-owned comics, carried by one of the medium's great visual stylists and a hero whose dry humour makes the weird feel human. A conventional first arc, a confusing publishing patchwork and a thinly drawn supporting cast keep it just below the very highest tier. An 8.9 recognises an excellent, influential saga whose best stories are genuinely timeless.




