Hollow Knight · 2017
Hollow Knight is a vast, melancholy kingdom that rewards every step into the dark
Hollow Knight review: Team Cherry's insect-kingdom metroidvania offers precise combat, vast exploration and haunting art, but its map system frustrates.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Hollow Knight is one of the defining independent games of its generation. A tiny team created a world of astonishing size and quality, a melancholy underground kingdom filled with secrets, lore and challenging combat. Its combination of exploration, atmosphere and precise action set a benchmark for the metroidvania genre that many later games have tried to match.
- 9.2
- Editorial score
- #24
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2017
- Released
- 9.5
- Best at: Longevity
It is also demanding and occasionally obtuse, with a map system and difficulty level that can frustrate. For players who embrace it, few games are as rewarding.
The hand-drawn art style is beautiful, with detailed backgrounds, expressive character designs and fluid animations.
How it plays
The Knight attacks with a nail, jumps and gains new abilities over time, such as a dash, wall climb and double jump. Soul, gathered by hitting enemies, can be used to heal or cast spells, creating a constant tension between offence and recovery.
Combat is precise and responsive, with enemies and bosses that telegraph their attacks but punish mistakes. Boss fights are a highlight, ranging from agile duellists to enormous creatures, and several optional encounters offer stern tests of skill.
Charms, equipped in limited slots, modify abilities in ways that allow varied builds, such as increasing attack range, speeding up healing or summoning allies.
Mapping is unusual. Players must buy maps of each area from a cartographer and use a quill to update them, and their location only appears with a specific charm. This can make early exploration confusing, though it adds to the sense of discovery.
Death leaves behind a shade that must be defeated to reclaim lost currency, in the manner of the Souls games, and long walks back to a shade can be frustrating before fast travel options expand.

World and story
Hallownest is a stunning setting. From the rain-soaked City of Tears to fungal wastes, crystal mines and eerie gardens, each area is distinct and atmospheric. The world is vast and densely packed with secrets, hidden paths and optional areas.
The story is subtle, conveyed through environmental details, cryptic dialogue and lore tablets. It tells of a fallen kingdom, a mysterious infection and a history of sacrifice. Characters such as Hornet, Quirrell and the cartographer Cornifer add warmth and mystery, and their stories reward attention.
Free updates added substantial new content, including new bosses, areas and challenges, contributing to the game's exceptional value. Its long-awaited follow-up, Hollow Knight: Silksong, eventually arrived in 2025.
Presentation
The hand-drawn art style is beautiful, with detailed backgrounds, expressive character designs and fluid animations. The palette shifts with each region, creating strong identities for areas.
Christopher Larkin's soundtrack is outstanding, blending melancholic piano and strings with grander themes in boss fights. Sound design is subtle and effective, enhancing the sense of loneliness and wonder.
What works
- Tight, precise combat with a huge roster of memorable bosses
- An enormous, interconnected world with a real sense of mystery
- Charms allow flexible builds that reshape how fights are approached
- Christopher Larkin's soundtrack is haunting and beautifully melancholic
What doesn’t
- Maps must be bought and updated manually, which confuses newcomers
- Long backtracking walks before fast travel options open up
- Late optional challenges are punishingly difficult
Head to head
- Story
- 8.66.3
- Gameplay
- 9.49.4
- Longevity
- 9.59.2
- Presentation
- 9.48.6
Hollow Knight edges it by 0.5. See them side by side
The verdict
Few metroidvanias offer this much world, this much atmosphere or combat this well tuned, and Hollow Knight earns its exceptional score on all three counts. The awkward map system, tiresome early backtracking and brutal optional content are genuine hurdles for newcomers, yet players who push through them will find one of the richest adventures the genre has produced.





