Horizon Forbidden West · 2022
Horizon Forbidden West is a stunning machine safari lost in open-world clutter
Horizon Forbidden West review: Guerrilla's sequel offers breathtaking visuals and thrilling machine hunts, but its busy structure and chatty lead grate.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Horizon Forbidden West is one of the most visually spectacular games ever made. Its landscapes, from lush forests and snowy peaks to sun-scorched deserts and ruined cities, are breathtaking, and its machines are imaginative, detailed and thrilling to fight.
- 8.1
- Editorial score
- #100
- Of 116 games reviewed
- 2022
- Released
- 9.8
- Best at: Presentation
Yet beneath the beauty lies a structure that feels overly familiar. Its map is crowded with activities, its dialogue can be exhausting, and its design sometimes lacks confidence in the player. It is an impressive and enjoyable sequel that nonetheless feels restrained by convention.
The Shieldwing lets Aloy glide, the Pullcaster works as a grappling hook, and underwater exploration opens new areas.
How it plays
Combat against machines is the highlight. Aloy can use a variety of bows, slings, traps and specialist tools to target machine components, stripping armour or removing weapons that she can then use herself. Understanding enemy weaknesses and planning attacks is rewarding, and fights against large machines are dramatic set pieces.
Melee combat has been expanded with combos and valor surges, special abilities that grant temporary advantages. Skill trees allow players to focus on different styles, such as stealth or ranged combat.
Human enemies are less satisfying. Fights against them lack the tactical depth of machine encounters, and melee remains clunky.
Exploration is improved with new tools. The Shieldwing lets Aloy glide, the Pullcaster works as a grappling hook, and underwater exploration opens new areas. Later, flying mounts allow players to soar across the map.
The open world is packed with activities, including settlements, rebel camps, arenas, races, collectibles and a strategy board game. Many are enjoyable, but their sheer number turns the map into a checklist.

World and story
The Forbidden West is a vivid setting, with tribes such as the Tenakth, Utaru and Oseram, each with distinct cultures and politics. Side quests often explore these communities, and many are well written.
The main story expands on the lore of Horizon Zero Dawn, delving into the history of the old world and introducing new threats. It is ambitious but exposition-heavy, and Aloy's personality can feel distant, especially when she rejects offers of help from companions.
Aloy's frequent commentary, often solving puzzles aloud before the player has a chance to think, drew particular criticism and is one of the most commonly cited irritations.
The Burning Shores expansion, set in a ruined Los Angeles, adds new areas, machines and story content.
Presentation
This is a stunning technical achievement. Environments are detailed and varied, with dramatic lighting, weather and vegetation. Character faces and animations are expressive, and cutscenes are impressive. On PS5, the game is a showcase for the hardware.
The soundtrack combines tribal influences and orchestral themes, and voice acting is strong, particularly from Ashly Burch as Aloy and the late Lance Reddick as Sylens.
What works
- Machine hunts reward tactical targeting of components and weaknesses
- Among the best-looking open worlds of its generation
- Tools like the glider and grappling hook improve exploration
- Supporting cast and tribal politics are richly developed
What doesn’t
- Map is cluttered with repetitive icons, activities and collectibles
- Aloy's constant commentary and hints undermine puzzle-solving
- Combat against human enemies is far weaker than machine fights
Head to head
- Story
- 7.68.3
- Gameplay
- 8.29.8
- Longevity
- 8.39.8
- Presentation
- 9.88.9
The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom edges it by 1.3. See them side by side
The verdict
As spectacle, Horizon Forbidden West is close to unmatched, and its machine hunts remain some of the most satisfying encounters in open-world games. The score is held down by a formulaic, overcrowded map, weak human combat and a design that explains too much, leaving an excellent-looking, very good game rather than a great one.





