How I Met Your Mother · 2005
How I Met Your Mother: a clever, sentimental sitcom undone by its own long game
Our review of How I Met Your Mother, the CBS sitcom about Ted Mosby's search for love: an inventive structure and loveable cast, stretched thin by a divisive finale.
Good
Editorial score out of 10
The CBS sitcom known to its fans as How I Met Your Mother began with a hook few sitcoms have attempted: a promise, built into the title, that a specific story was being told towards a specific destination. Its unreliable narration, time-hopping flashbacks and elaborate callbacks gave it a playfulness that set it apart from other multi-camera comedies of its era, and its core cast developed a warmth that made it a durable hit.
- 7.2
- Editorial score
- #92
- Of 109 series reviewed
- 2005
- Released
- 9
- Seasons
The same structure, though, became a burden. A premise designed to reach an ending had to sustain nine seasons, and the show's final years and conclusion left many longtime viewers deeply dissatisfied.
Scenes cut abruptly to fantasies, alternate versions of events and future flash-forwards, often in a single episode.
Story
The early seasons are the show's best. Ted's romantic misadventures, including his on-off relationship with Robin, are framed by a narrator who reveals and withholds information for comic effect. Episodes play with chronology, fold small details into running jokes that pay off years later and build a rich shared mythology of bar arguments, bets and invented rules. At its peak, it has the ingenuity of a puzzle box inside a traditional sitcom.
As the seasons pass, the need to postpone the title's payoff creates strain. Relationships begin and end with a sense of repetition, and some storylines seem designed mainly to fill time. The final season, set across a single long weekend, is an experiment that divided viewers, and the finale's choices provoked a backlash that still shapes the show's reputation. Whether one accepts that ending or not, the path to it is uneven.

Characters and performances
Neil Patrick Harris is the breakout star. Barney, with his suits, schemes and catchphrases, could have been a one-joke character, but Harris's timing and commitment, and the writers' gradual addition of vulnerability, make him the most entertaining presence in the show. Jason Segel and Alyson Hannigan are delightful as Marshall and Lily, a couple whose affection feels genuine and whose marriage is rendered with unusual sweetness. Cobie Smulders gives Robin a dry, independent wit.
Josh Radnor has the hardest job. Ted is intended as a hopeless romantic, but his self-absorption and moralising grow tiresome across the years, which is a significant problem for a show narrated from his perspective. Cristin Milioti, arriving late in the run, is immediately charming and leaves viewers wishing they had seen more.
Craft
The show's editing and structure are more ambitious than most multi-camera sitcoms. Scenes cut abruptly to fantasies, alternate versions of events and future flash-forwards, often in a single episode. Its sets, particularly the bar where the group gathers, are cosy and familiar, and its original songs became cult favourites. The laugh track and broad staging keep it rooted in a traditional format.
Who it is for
Fans of ensemble sitcoms will enjoy its first four or five seasons immensely. Viewers who care about story endings should be aware of the controversy and decide whether the journey is worth it. Some of Barney's humour has aged poorly.
What works
- Playful narration with flashbacks and running gags rewards attention
- Neil Patrick Harris turns Barney into a comic tour de force
- Marshall and Lily's marriage is one of sitcom's warmest relationships
- Cristin Milioti makes a late arrival instantly compelling
What doesn’t
- Middle and late seasons tread water to delay the central reveal
- The finale divided its audience and recast what came before
- Ted's romantic self-absorption becomes wearing over nine seasons
Head to head
- Craft
- 7.86.3
- Story
- 6.65.8
- Characters
- 7.66.8
- Performances
- 8.27.6
How I Met Your Mother edges it by 0.8. See them side by side
The verdict
How I Met Your Mother earns a 7.2 for its inventive storytelling devices, a loveable cast and a peak run of seasons that are genuinely clever. It is held back by repetitive later years, a wearing central character and a finale that undercut the story it spent so long telling.





