Skip to content

Head to head

How I Met Your Mother vs The Big Bang Theory

How I Met Your Mother takes it by 0.8, 7.2 against 6.4. The subscores below show where the gap actually is.

Cover of How I Met Your Mother
  • Playful narration with flashbacks and running gags rewards attention
  • Neil Patrick Harris turns Barney into a comic tour de force
  • Middle and late seasons tread water to delay the central reveal
Cover of The Big Bang Theory
The Big Bang Theory

2007 · Mixed

  • Jim Parsons turns Sheldon's rigid eccentricities into precise comedy
  • Tight joke construction delivers consistent laughs per minute
  • Much humour laughs at nerd culture rather than with it

Where the gap is

Craft
7.86.3
Story
6.65.8
Characters
7.66.8
Performances
8.27.6

At a glance

FactHow I Met Your MotherThe Big Bang Theory
Released19 September 200524 September 2007
Created byCarter Bays, Craig ThomasChuck Lorre, Bill Prady
StarringJason Segel, Neil Patrick Harris, Cobie SmuldersJim Parsons, Johnny Galecki, Kaley Cuoco
NetworkCBSCBS
Seasons912
Episodes208279
GenreComedy · RomanceComedy · Romance

The two verdicts

How I Met Your Mother

How I Met Your Mother: a clever, sentimental sitcom undone by its own long game

How I Met Your Mother earns a 7.2 for its inventive storytelling devices, a loveable cast and a peak run of seasons that are genuinely clever. It is held back by repetitive later years, a wearing central character and a finale that undercut the story it spent so long telling.

Read the full review →

The Big Bang Theory

The Big Bang Theory: a hugely popular sitcom whose affection for geeks runs shallow

The Big Bang Theory is a professionally assembled crowd-pleaser with a standout lead performance and a strong ensemble. Its reliance on stereotypes, its tired formula and its surface-level treatment of the culture it portrays keep it from greatness. A 6.4 reflects a show that delivered laughs for millions but offers little depth for anyone seeking more.

Read the full review →

Both scored on the same ten-point scale, by the same desk. How we score.