Killers of the Flower Moon · 2023
Killers of the Flower Moon: Scorsese's patient, damning epic of American greed
Killers of the Flower Moon review: Martin Scorsese's Osage murders epic is a sombre, powerful work led by a superb Lily Gladstone, if its length is punishing.
Excellent
Editorial score out of 10
Killers of the Flower Moon is Martin Scorsese's most sombre epic, a film about greed, betrayal and systemic violence against the Osage Nation in 1920s Oklahoma. Adapted from David Grann's bestselling account, it transforms a true crime story into a portrait of complicity, showing how murder became an ordinary business for people who professed to love their victims. It was widely acclaimed as one of Scorsese's major late works, and Lily Gladstone's performance earned particular praise.
- 8.6
- Editorial score
- #53
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 9.3
- Best at: Performances
Its length and deliberate pacing are challenging, and not every narrative choice is fully successful. But its moral seriousness and craft make it essential viewing.
The film's closing sequence, which should not be spoiled, is a bold and unexpected meditation on how such stories are told and consumed.
A different story
Grann's book is structured partly as a detective story, following the early federal investigators who uncovered the murders. Scorsese and Eric Roth famously restructured the adaptation to focus instead on the relationship between Ernest and Mollie, and on the conspiracy from the inside. This means that the audience knows much of what is happening long before the investigation arrives, turning the film from a mystery into a study of how evil operates.
The decision is powerful and ethically considered, avoiding a narrative in which white lawmen become the heroes of an Osage tragedy. Scorsese worked closely with members of the Osage Nation, and filming took place in Osage County. The price is a certain dramatic inertia in the long middle section, where the pattern of death and deceit repeats.

Ernest, Hale and Mollie
Leonardo DiCaprio plays Ernest as a greedy, weak and not very clever man, perpetually frowning under his uncle's influence. It is a brave, unglamorous performance, but Ernest's lack of self-awareness can make his scenes frustrating, and the film spends a great deal of time with him.
Robert De Niro is superb as William Hale, the self-described friend of the Osage who flatters their elders, funds their community and orchestrates their murders. His paternal, soft-spoken manner makes his cruelty all the more chilling.
Lily Gladstone is the film's heart. Mollie is witty, observant and dignified, fully aware of why Ernest is courting her, yet she chooses to love him. Gladstone conveys her intelligence and pain with remarkable stillness. The film's major flaw is that Mollie spends much of the later stretch bedridden by illness, which reduces her presence precisely when her perspective is most needed.
Craft
Rodrigo Prieto's cinematography captures the Oklahoma plains with sweeping beauty, and the recreation of the boomtown of Fairfax is detailed and lived-in. The late Robbie Robertson's score, built on a pulsing, bluesy rhythm, evokes both Native music and a heartbeat of dread. Thelma Schoonmaker's editing is patient, allowing scenes to breathe.
The film's closing sequence, which should not be spoiled, is a bold and unexpected meditation on how such stories are told and consumed.
Length
At 206 minutes, the film is demanding. Its patience serves the story's cumulative horror, but viewers may find the middle hours repetitive, and a tighter version could have strengthened its impact.
What works
- Lily Gladstone's quiet, commanding Mollie is the film's soul
- Robert De Niro makes Hale's folksy menace deeply chilling
- Refuses to frame the story as a heroic FBI investigation
- Robbie Robertson's score is spare, rhythmic and haunting
What doesn’t
- At 206 minutes, the middle section drags significantly
- Mollie is sidelined in the later stretch as illness overtakes her
- Ernest's dim passivity can make the drama frustrating
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.09.5
- Story
- 8.38.6
- Direction
- 9.29.3
- Performances
- 9.39.4
Oppenheimer edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
Killers of the Flower Moon is a powerful, beautifully crafted and morally urgent epic, with extraordinary performances from Gladstone and De Niro. Its length, frustrating protagonist and the reduced presence of Mollie late on prevent it from being a flawless work. It earns an 8.6.





