Oppenheimer · 2023
Oppenheimer: Nolan's three-hour biopic plays like a thriller of conscience
Oppenheimer review: Christopher Nolan's epic about the father of the atomic bomb is dense, gripping and superbly acted, with a demanding structure.
Essential
Editorial score out of 10
Oppenheimer takes one of the most consequential lives of the twentieth century and turns it into something closer to a psychological thriller than a conventional biopic. Christopher Nolan builds the film around a question he never fully answers: what happens inside a person who makes the unthinkable possible, and then has to live in the world he helped create? The result is dense, relentless and often overwhelming, in the best and occasionally the most exhausting senses.
- 9.0
- Editorial score
- #30
- Of 112 movies reviewed
- 2023
- Released
- 9.5
- Best at: Craft
It is also, perhaps surprisingly for a film about a bomb, mostly people talking in rooms. That Nolan makes those rooms feel as tense as any of his action sequences is the film's great achievement.
Both actors won Academy Awards, as did the film itself for Best Picture.
Story and structure
The screenplay moves on two tracks. In colour, largely from Oppenheimer's perspective, it charts his rise through European physics, his left-wing associations in Berkeley, and his appointment to lead the scientific effort at Los Alamos. In stark black and white, it follows Lewis Strauss, a powerful government figure whose relationship with Oppenheimer has soured, during a later Senate confirmation process. Interwoven with both is a closed security hearing in 1954 that picks apart Oppenheimer's past.
This structure gives the film its shape and its payoff, but it is demanding. Names, committees and scientific rivalries arrive in a torrent, and the first hour in particular can feel like reading a dense history at speed. Patient viewers will find the threads converge powerfully in the final hour, which reframes much of what came before.

Direction and craft
Nolan and cinematographer Hoyte van Hoytema shot on large-format film, including black-and-white stock made specially for the production, and the imagery is extraordinary even in the many close-ups of faces. Recurring visions of particles, waves and fire suggest how Oppenheimer might have seen the universe, without ever becoming a lecture.
The Trinity test is the centrepiece, and it is handled with rare restraint: Nolan uses light first and sound later, and the gap between them is where the sequence becomes unbearable. Just as effective is a scene shortly afterwards, in which a triumphant speech curdles into horror, rendered almost entirely through sound design and Murphy's face. Ludwig Goransson's score, built around insistent strings, keeps pulse and pressure high through long dialogue passages, though the overall mix sometimes drowns out the words.
Performances
Cillian Murphy was the natural choice for a man described as both magnetic and unknowable, and he rises to it with a performance of enormous control. Robert Downey Jr., playing against his familiar persona, is superb as Strauss: prickly, proud and dangerous. Both actors won Academy Awards, as did the film itself for Best Picture.
Emily Blunt makes a strong impression as Oppenheimer's wife Kitty, especially in one late confrontation, and Matt Damon's blunt, practical General Groves is a welcome source of humour. The film is less generous to its women than its men, though, and Florence Pugh's Jean Tatlock in particular exists more as a symptom of Oppenheimer's inner life than as a person. Among the supporting cast, Benny Safdie as Edward Teller and Josh Hartnett as Ernest Lawrence stand out.
Who it is for
This is essential for anyone interested in history, science or ambitious studio filmmaking, and it rewards a big screen and full attention. Viewers who find talk-heavy dramas hard going, or who expect a war film with extended action, may struggle across three hours. It focuses closely on the men who built the weapon, and some critics noted the limits of that perspective.
What works
- Cillian Murphy conveys brilliance and hollowing guilt, often through his eyes alone
- Robert Downey Jr. is a revelation as the prickly, wounded Lewis Strauss
- The Trinity test sequence is a staggering fusion of image, sound and silence
- Ludwig Goransson's score gives three hours of talk real forward momentum
What doesn’t
- Wall-to-wall dialogue and a crowded cast make the first hour hard to follow
- Female characters, especially Kitty and Jean Tatlock, feel underwritten
- Some aggressive sound mixing buries key lines of dialogue
Head to head
- Craft
- 9.59.0
- Story
- 8.68.3
- Direction
- 9.39.2
- Performances
- 9.49.3
Oppenheimer edges it by 0.4. See them side by side
The verdict
Oppenheimer is a remarkable piece of filmmaking: a serious, adult historical drama delivered with blockbuster conviction, and a huge popular and critical success. Its performances and craft are close to flawless. A punishing information load, thin female roles and a sometimes muddy sound mix keep it from landmark status, but it is among Nolan's finest and most mature work.





