Skip to content
Device reviewGood

Amazon Kindle (first generation) · 2007

Amazon Kindle (first generation): the awkward machine that started a category

Amazon Kindle (first generation) review. The clumsy 2007 e-reader whose free wireless bookshop, not its hardware, changed how books are sold.

Voxizer EditorialSection editor Pablo Huguet10 min read

Good

Editorial score out of 10

The first Kindle is mostly keyboard. A six-inch screen sits in the top half of a white plastic wedge, and below it runs a full QWERTY layout of small angled keys, the sort of thing a phone carried in 2007 and a book has never needed. Down the right-hand edge there is a scroll wheel with its own narrow silver strip beside it, because the screen could not draw a cursor fast enough to follow a finger. The machine looks like a product that lost an argument with its own feature list.

7.2
Editorial score
#33
Of 37 devices reviewed
2007
Released
8.2
Best at: Features

Judge it as hardware and it is poor, and it was poor at the time. Judge it as the first working answer to a question publishers had spent a decade avoiding — how do you get a book onto a screen without a computer standing in the way — and it is among the most consequential things Amazon has ever shipped. Both of those are true at once, and the distance between them is the whole story of the original Kindle.

The complaints that have followed the first Kindle for nearly twenty years are almost never about the display.

What Amazon sold

Amazon announced the Kindle on 19 November 2007 and put it on sale the same day. The press release promised more than 90,000 titles, most new releases and bestsellers at $9.99, newspapers and magazines by subscription, and blogs updated through the day. The hardware was almost an afterthought in that announcement, which is revealing: what Amazon was selling was a shop that happened to come with a screen attached.

The screen was six inches of E Ink electronic paper, 600 by 800 pixels at 167 pixels per inch, with four greys and no light of its own. Behind it sat 256 MB of storage, about 180 MB of which the reader could actually fill, an SD slot for cards up to 4 GB, a rear-mounted mono speaker for MP3 and Audible files, and a removable 1,530 mAh battery under a textured back cover printed with letterforms from a dozen alphabets. It weighed 10.3 ounces and measured 7.5 by 5.3 by 0.7 inches.

What made it a Kindle rather than a reader with a bookshop bolted on was Whispernet: an EVDO modem riding Sprint's American cellular network, with the data paid for by Amazon. No Wi-Fi, no hotspots, no monthly bill, no pairing with a computer. You searched, you bought, and the book arrived in under a minute. Everything sold to the device stayed in your account, so a lost Kindle did not mean a lost library.

  1. September 2006

    Sony's Reader brings E Ink to American shops, with books loaded from a PC

  2. 19 November 2007

    Amazon announces the Kindle at $399 with more than 90,000 titles, and sells the first run out in five and a half hours

  3. April 2008

    Supply catches up, after roughly five months with nothing to sell

  4. February 2009

    The Kindle 2 replaces it: thinner, sealed shut, no SD slot

  5. October 2009

    An international edition finally puts a Kindle in British hands

The sell-out is usually told as a triumph, and it was certainly a surprise inside Amazon. It was also a failure of planning that left the category's only credible device unavailable through most of its first year, which is a long time to hand a rival a free run at the market. Nobody took it.

Amazon Kindle (first generation)
Amazon Kindle (first generation)Photograph by ShakataGaNai, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The screen

E Ink in 2007 did one thing superbly and several things badly, and the Kindle inherited both halves. In sunlight it is better than any backlit panel made since, because it reflects rather than emits; the text sits on the surface like ink on a page, and the contrast improves as the light gets harder. Leave the device on a table and the page stays there, drawing nothing. Battery life was measured in days with the radio on and a week or more with it off, a scale of endurance no other screen could offer.

The badly-done half is motion. Every page turn repaints the whole display, which at this generation meant a black flash and a pause long enough to notice. Menus feel slow because they are built from the same full refreshes. The web browser, an experiment Amazon labelled as such, renders pages in four greys over a cellular connection designed for text, and is best understood as a party trick that happened to include Wikipedia. Four greys also means photographs arrive as approximations, which is why the device is so much happier with a novel than with anything illustrated.

What Amazon shipped
PartWhat the 2007 Kindle had
Display6-inch E Ink, 600 × 800 at 167 ppi, four greys, no light of its own
Storage256 MB, about 180 MB usable, plus an SD slot for cards up to 4 GB
WirelessEVDO with 1xRTT fallback on Sprint's network, free of charge, United States only
BatteryRemovable 1,530 mAh pack; a week with the radio off, about two hours to charge
Body7.5 × 5.3 × 0.7 inches, 10.3 ounces, QWERTY keyboard, scroll wheel

Read a plain novel on it and the screen does its job without comment, which is the highest praise an e-reader screen can earn. The complaints that have followed the first Kindle for nearly twenty years are almost never about the display.

The body

They are about everything around it. The page-turn bars run the full height of both edges, so the natural way to hold the device — thumb on the left, fingers behind — turns a page every time you adjust your grip. The back is wedged rather than flat, which makes it rock on a table and sit oddly in a bag. The keyboard occupies a third of the front for a job most readers do perhaps twice an hour, and its angled keys are cramped enough that search is a chore rather than a feature. The scroll wheel, with its separate cursor channel, is the most dated thing on the device and was already dated when it shipped.

There are good decisions in here too, and they tend to be the ones Amazon dropped later. The battery comes out with a fingernail. The SD slot means the storage is yours to extend. The supplied cover is a proper book-style case rather than an accessory to be bought separately. Open the back and the thing is legible as a machine: a model number, a battery with its rating printed on it, a reset hole. Later Kindles are better objects and far less honest ones.

How it stands up now

Screen
8/10
Readable in daylight, four greys, no light of its own
Body
4/10
Page bars on both edges turn pages you did not mean to turn
Wireless
9/10
A book in under a minute, anywhere in the States, at no cost
Choice at launch
7/10
More than 90,000 titles, nearly all in Amazon's own format
Use today
2/10
The network it needs is gone; books go on by cable or not at all

Set it beside the Sony Reader and the iRex iLiad, the two devices it had to beat, and the Kindle is the ugliest of the three. It is also the only one you could buy a book on while sitting on a bus.

Gallery · 3 imagesPhotograph by ShakataGaNai, CC BY 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Photograph by ShakataGaNai, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons · Photograph by John Blyberg, CC BY 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons

The store, and the lock

This is where the first Kindle stops being a gadget and starts being a strategy. Buying a book on the Sony Reader meant a computer, a cable and a piece of desktop software. Buying one on the Kindle meant typing a title and waiting. That difference looks small written down and was enormous in practice, because it removed the one step at which most people gave up.

The price of that convenience was the format. Books arrived as AZW, Amazon's own wrapper around Mobipocket, with digital rights management that tied them to an Amazon account. Plain text, unprotected MOBI and PRC files could be side-loaded, and documents could be emailed to the device for ten cents each, so the Kindle was never sealed. But the catalogue was. Every purchase made the next device easier to choose and a rival's harder, and that was the point of selling the hardware at all.

The Kindle 2 arrived fifteen months later, thinner and sealed, with the SD slot and the removable battery gone and the keyboard shrunk but kept. The direction of travel was already set: fewer hatches, fewer buttons, more store. By the time of the Kindle Scribe the hardware had become a sheet of glass with a pen, and the thing being sold had not changed at all.

Where it sits now

Nobody should read on this device today, and plenty of people still do. What survives is the argument it won. Every modern e-reader — Amazon's own, Kobo's, reMarkable's — is a refinement of the proposition the 2007 Kindle made: a reflective screen, a battery measured in weeks, and a catalogue that reaches the device without a computer. The Kobo Libra Colour is a better object in every measurable way and is still having the same conversation.

The honest British footnote is that none of this happened here. Amazon never sold the first-generation Kindle outside the United States, and no Kindle was available in the United Kingdom until the international edition of its successor in October 2009. For a British reader this device is a historical object rather than a memory, which is a slightly different relationship than American owners have with it.

Head to head

Value
6.27.2
Design
5.58.4
Features
8.26.5
Performance
6.86.9

Dead level: both score 7.2.See them side by side

Compare the two and the first Kindle's one lasting advantage shows up immediately: it is a machine you can open. The battery lifts out, the storage is a card, the firmware is a Linux kernel with a visible file system when you plug it in. That is worth something to a collector and nothing at all to a reader.

For you if

  • Collectors of first-generation hardware, who will find this one unusually well documented
  • Anyone curious about why e-readers settled on the shape they did
  • Readers who will side-load their own files and never need the store

Not for you if

  • Anyone who wants to read a book bought in the last fifteen years
  • Readers outside the United States, for whom the wireless never worked at all
  • Anyone who finds accidental page turns more than a minor irritation

If the history is what interests you, the launch announcement is still online and still the clearest statement of what Amazon thought it was doing.

What works

  • E Ink that still reads like paper in daylight, with no light of its own
  • Whispernet delivers a book over cellular in a minute, with no computer and no bill
  • A replaceable battery and an SD slot, both gone from every Kindle since

What doesn’t

  • Page bars run the full height of both edges, so pages turn by accident
  • A full keyboard and a wedge-shaped back make it clumsy to hold for a chapter
  • Sold only in the United States, on a cellular network long since switched off
GoodHow we score

The verdict

The first Kindle is a poor piece of industrial design wrapped around an excellent idea. The screen is still good, the free cellular delivery was genuinely new, and the removable battery and SD slot are small acts of generosity that no later Kindle repeated. Against that: a body that turns pages by itself, a keyboard that earns no space, a scroll wheel that was obsolete on the day, a price of $399 that bought a device only Americans could use, and a catalogue locked to one shop. Scored as a device rather than as a turning point, it lands at good rather than great. The turning point it certainly was, and the two judgements do not have to agree.

Quick answers

Is Amazon Kindle (first generation) worth buying?

Voxizer scores Amazon Kindle (first generation) (2007) 7.2 out of 10 — good. The first Kindle is a poor piece of industrial design wrapped around an excellent idea. The screen is still good, the free cellular delivery was genuinely new, and the removable battery and SD slot are small acts of generosity that no later Kindle repeated.

Who will enjoy Amazon Kindle (first generation)?

Collectors of first-generation hardware, who will find this one unusually well documented. Anyone curious about why e-readers settled on the shape they did. Readers who will side-load their own files and never need the store.

Who should skip Amazon Kindle (first generation)?

Anyone who wants to read a book bought in the last fifteen years. Readers outside the United States, for whom the wireless never worked at all. Anyone who finds accidental page turns more than a minor irritation.

What is Amazon Kindle (first generation) like, in short?

The body is the weak part: a wedge-shaped back, a keyboard nobody asked for, and page bars that turn pages by accident. The screen was the argument, and E Ink still reads like paper in full daylight. Whispernet — free cellular delivery, no computer, no bill — is the invention everyone else copied. At $399 and sold only in the United States, it was never a British purchase.

What readers say

Written by Voxizer members and checked by our moderators before they appear.

Written reviews

–

No written reviews yet

Write a review
9–10
0
7–8.5
0
5–6.5
0
3–4.5
0
0–2.5
0

Nobody has reviewed Amazon Kindle (first generation) yet. Be the first.

All reviews →

Verified sources

Published by the Voxizer editorial team — David Abellán, Ignacio Pineda, Pablo Huguet. Section editor for devices: Pablo Huguet.

Revision history

  1. Published

Scores are revised when the facts behind them change, and the change is recorded here. How we score.